OpenNashPodcasts

Leadership Next (Fortune)

Citi CEO Jane Fraser is Bringing Empathy to Banking

29 Nov 2022 · 35m · Jane Fraser, Alan Murray, Ellen McGirt · 24 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Citi CEO Jane Fraser argues that culture, diversity and empathy are not side projects but core tools for turning around a troubled bank. She calls empathy a hard skill that creates competitive edge, because listening to clients and staff produces better solutions and helps attract and keep talent.

The tension running through the conversation is between pragmatism and politics. Fraser lays out a measured economic outlook, hybrid work, public diversity targets and cautious crypto stance, while insisting the bank ignores political noise and just gets on with the job. She also describes her own career trade-offs, including part-time work at McKinsey.

Key insights

  1. Fraser treats empathy as a hard business skill

    She says empathy is not about being nice but about listening to clients so the bank sells what they need, not what it wants. She argues it also makes Citi an employer of choice.

  2. Fraser expects recession in Europe first, US later

    She names rates, recession and Russia as converging pressures, sees Europe at or near recession, and says a US downturn is more likely in the second half of next year. Persistent services inflation means rates stay high for long.

  3. Citi chose hybrid work based on its own evidence

    Fraser says the bank closed its books a day early with no one in a city office, showing full presence is not needed. Citi still wants people together for collaboration, apprenticeship and belonging.

  4. Public targets and pay audits force accountability

    Citi publishes representation targets and pay gap data, with a third party measuring pay equity. Fraser says making commitments public works as a forcing device so progress does not slip.

  5. Banks avoided crypto because guardrails were missing

    Fraser says blockchain has promise, but the parallel crypto ecosystem lacks protections against fraud, money laundering and consumer harm. She says large banks invested in the underlying technology but held back from products, citing the need to protect ordinary investors.

Questions

Why does Jane Fraser call empathy a hard skill?

She says empathy is not about being nice but about giving the bank a competitive edge. Listening closely to clients leads to solutions that fit their needs, and it helps Citi attract and retain a diverse workforce.

Is the US heading into a recession, according to Citi's CEO?

Fraser says Europe is likely heading into or already in recession, while the US is strong now, with healthy consumers and jobs. She thinks a US recession, if it comes, is more likely in the second half of next year.

What is Citi's policy on working from home?

Citi chose a hybrid model, with most staff asked to come in two or three days a week. Traders are in about five days, while call center staff come in less.

Why didn't big banks like Citi jump into crypto?

Fraser says the crypto ecosystem lacks guardrails such as investor protection and defenses against fraud and money laundering. She says banks invested in the underlying technology but avoided material engagement with the products.

How does Citi track diversity and pay equity?

Citi set public targets, including at least 40% women in its 100,000 most senior roles, and says it exceeded the earlier goal. It also has a third party measure pay equity and publishes both adjusted and raw pay gaps.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Jane Fraser is described by Alan Murray as the first woman to be CEO of Citi and the first woman to run a big Wall Street bank.

“We talked to Jane Fraser, the CEO of Citi, the first woman to be CEO in the bank's history, really the first woman to run a big Wall Street bank.”

0:00:39 · Alan Murray · Citi leadership · 2021

Jane Fraser became CEO of Citi in March 2021.

“She, as you don't know, she became CEO of Citi in March of 2021, which was such a difficult time for the world and the bank.”

0:01:51 · Ellen McGirt · CEO appointment · 2021

Before becoming Citi CEO, Jane Fraser was CEO of Citigroup Latin America.

“She had been the CEO of Citigroup Latin America at the time.”

0:01:23 · Ellen McGirt · Career · 2019

Some commentators raised the idea of a glass cliff when Jane Fraser was appointed Citi CEO.

“there were some people who raised that notion of the glass cliff, that women get the jobs where you're most likely to fail because it's such a difficult job.”

0:01:58 · Alan Murray · Glass cliff · 2021

Jane Fraser named rates, recession and Russia as three forces converging on the global economy, especially in Europe.

“There are three R's that are having an impact on the world at the moment. That's rates, that's recession, and it's Russia.”

0:03:23 · Jane Fraser · Economy · 2022

Fraser said a US recession, if one came, was more likely in the second half of the following year because the economy was strong.

“US, if we go into one, more likely in the second half of next year, because right now the economy is pretty strong.”

0:03:23 · Jane Fraser · Recession outlook · 2022

Fraser said goods inflation was falling quickly while services inflation remained the main problem.

“The goods inflation is really coming off quite quickly. It's all about services.”

0:04:59 · Jane Fraser · Inflation · 2022

Fraser said her turnaround sequence at Citi began with vision, then strategy, talent and culture, and then operational transformation.

“We started off with vision, then moved to strategy, looking at talent and culture, and then what are the transformation we needed of our operations and risk and controls and others to support it.”

0:06:03 · Jane Fraser · Turnaround strategy · 2021

Fraser said the two values she wanted Citi known for were excellence and empathy.

“We want to be known for excellence.”

0:06:49 · Jane Fraser · Culture · 2021

Alan Murray said Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon had called for everyone to return to the office.

“David Solomon, Goldman Sachs said a year ago, I want everybody back in the office. We're an in-office culture.”

0:11:14 · Alan Murray · Return to office · 2021

Citi, under Jane Fraser, announced a hybrid work model early in her tenure.

“you said right off the bat, we're going to be a hybrid culture.”

0:11:37 · Alan Murray · Hybrid work · 2021

Fraser said Citi closed its books a day early with no staff in a city office, showing remote work could function.

“I still remember the day that we closed the books for the first time with not one person in a Citi office. And we closed a day ahead of when we normally do.”

0:11:56 · Jane Fraser · Remote work · 2020

Fraser said Citi's traders generally work in the office about five days a week.

“So our traders tend to be here pretty well five days a week.”

0:14:06 · Jane Fraser · Hybrid work · 2022

Citi met and slightly exceeded the three-year representation goals set by Fraser's predecessor Mike Corbett.

“Mike had set three-year goals. We met them in terms of representation. In fact, we exceeded them by a bit, which is always good.”

0:17:13 · Jane Fraser · Diversity targets · 2022

Citi set a target of at least 40% women in its 100,000 most senior roles, out of 220,000 roles, and says it exceeded it.

“We wanted 40 % or above to be helped by women for the 100,000 most senior roles.”

0:17:49 · Jane Fraser · Gender representation · 2022

Citi has a third party measure pay equity and publishes both its adjusted and raw pay gaps.

“We have a third party do the measurement. And we publish externally what is our adjusted pay gap, but then what the raw pay gap is.”

0:19:30 · Jane Fraser · Pay equity · 2022

Alan Murray said the governor of Florida was attacking companies that adopt ESG as woke.

“The governor of Florida, who may well be the Republican nominee for president at this point, is attacking companies that adopt ESG as being woke corporations”

0:20:54 · Alan Murray · ESG backlash · 2022

Fraser said Citi operates in almost 100 countries and has been in most of them for over a century.

“As a bank that works in almost 100 countries around the world and has done in most of those countries for over a century”

0:25:01 · Jane Fraser · Global footprint · 2022

Alan Murray referred to the recent collapse of crypto trading platform FTX.

“And then we just recently had the meltdown of one of the biggest platforms that people were trading on, FTX.”

0:25:57 · Alan Murray · Crypto · 2022

Fraser said large banks invested in blockchain technology but avoided crypto products because investor protections were lacking.

“you have not seen material engagement with the products because we believe firmly we need to have the investor protections in particular because grandma is investing in crypto.”

0:27:03 · Jane Fraser · Crypto banking · 2022

Fraser worked part-time at McKinsey right after becoming a partner, for about five years.

“I also worked for a firm, this was McKinsey when I moved part-time as a partner, right when I made partner, and they supported me”

0:29:43 · Jane Fraser · Career

Fraser said she moved from the UK to the US partly because she thought it would better support senior female leaders.

“was one of the reasons I actively moved from the UK to the US because I felt this would be an ecosystem that would be more supportive of senior female leaders.”

0:29:13 · Jane Fraser · Career

Fraser said extending health benefits to unmarried and same-sex partners at Citi lowered healthcare costs for all employees.

“it brought down the cost of health care for everybody in the institution.”

0:32:49 · Jane Fraser · Benefits

Fraser said she grew up in a town that lost manufacturing to Asia and had local coal mines closed.

“I grew up in a town that saw manufacturing move from that town to Asia and saw coal mines locally get shut down.”

0:23:34 · Jane Fraser · Background

Chapters

  1. 0:01:58Introducing Jane Fraser and the glass cliff

    The hosts frame Fraser's March 2021 appointment as a turnaround job and explain why culture is central to her approach.

    “her focus on culture and diversity is all critical to her notion of how you engineer a turnaround.”
  2. 0:03:23Three R's and the outlook for inflation

    Fraser outlines her view of the global economy, with Europe in recession first and the US later, and why services inflation is stubborn.

    “there are three R's that are having an impact on the world at the moment.”
  3. 0:08:35Vision, culture and empathy as a hard skill

    Fraser explains how she sequenced the turnaround and why she made empathy and excellence the bank's two guiding values.

    “I view empathy as a hard skill. It's not soft. This isn't about being nice.”
  4. 0:11:56Hybrid work at Citi

    Fraser describes why Citi chose hybrid work rather than a full return to the office and how it varies by job.

    “we closed a day ahead of when we normally do.”
  5. 0:18:58Targets, pay equity and inclusion

    Fraser details Citi's public representation targets and pay gap reporting, and why inclusion must be built into daily operations.

    “Transparency works. Making those commitments public definitely helps as a forcing device”
  6. 0:23:34ESG, politics and crypto

    Fraser responds to backlash against ESG and explains why banks held back from crypto after the FTX collapse.

    “I believe it's just called getting on with the day job. It's noise versus signal.”
  7. 0:31:02Career choices and the turnaround scorecard

    Fraser recounts working part-time at McKinsey and assesses how far Citi's multi-year transformation has come.

    “if I hadn't done that, I wouldn't be in the seat I'm in today.”

Transcript

0:00:04
Alan Murray

Leadership Next is powered by the folks at Deloitte, who, like me, are super focused on how CEOs can lead in the context of disruption and devolving societal expectations. Welcome to Leadership Next, the podcast about the changing rules of business leadership. I'm Alan Murray, CEO of Fortune Media, and I'm here with my incomparable co-host, Ellen McGirt. Ellen.

0:00:30
Ellen McGirt

Ellen, I love those introductions. I am not the CEO of Fortune Media, but I sure am a happy reporter in the Fortune Media shop. We've got a really great episode today, don't we?

0:00:39
Alan Murray

It's a special one for a couple of reasons. We talked to Jane Fraser, the CEO of Citi, the first woman to be CEO in the bank's history, really the first woman to run a big Wall Street bank. The other reason it was special is that all three of us were in the same room together. It was not virtual. It was the real thing.

0:00:58
Ellen McGirt

like pre-COVID type stuff. I know. And our producer was there and it was just so exciting. It was very cool to be able to sit together and see each other and see each other's response to everything instead of just talking through multiple screens. And it reminded me of the vision that we had for this podcast way before the pandemic started. And by the way, I know Jane

0:01:18
Alan Murray

is someone you've wanted to get on the podcast since the day she became CEO. Tell us why.

0:01:23
Ellen McGirt

Yes. I first met her in late 2019, actually at Citi headquarters to talk about women and women in banking and equity and building trust within the financial system. She had been the CEO of Citigroup Latin America at the time. And she kind of blew me away with her very succinct and clear vision about gender and equity and what that meant in financial services and what that meant in the world. and her particular journey has been so impressive to me.

0:01:51

She, as you don't know, she became CEO of Citi in March of 2021, which was such a difficult time for the world and the bank.

0:01:58
Alan Murray

Yeah, and I would emphasize that it was a difficult time for the bank. I mean, this was really considered a turnaround job. In fact, if you look at the coverage at the time she was appointed, there were some people who raised that notion of the glass cliff, that women get the jobs where you're most likely to fail because it's such a difficult job. But what's so fascinating about the conversation we had with her is that her focus on culture and diversity is all critical to her notion of how you engineer a turnaround.

0:02:29

It's not something you do on the side. It's core to her view on how you make a successful company.

0:02:36
Ellen McGirt

Absolutely. And I do believe that Fortune, the Most Powerful Women community in particular, talk a lot about that glass cliff. And we were able to talk a little bit with Jane about how this community of executive women have mean so much to each other and talk about empathy.

0:02:50
Alan Murray

Who knew there was empathy in banking? Jane also had some interesting thoughts about the current economy, the return to office debate, which is a hot one in the financial sector in New York, and the cryptocurrency meltdown. So let's get right into it. I'd like to start by talking about what's on top of everyone's mind. which is the state of the economy. A lot of crazy data going back and forth. You have better data than we do.

0:03:18

So tell us what's really going on. Are we headed into a recession or are we not?

0:03:23
Jane Fraser

Well, it depends a little bit where in the world you are. If we take the step back, I'd say there are three R's that are having an impact on the world at the moment. That's rates, that's recession, and it's Russia. They're all converging in Europe right now. So we certainly see Europe heading into a recession. if it's not already in one. And we expect a rolling series of recessions around the world. US, if we go into one, more likely in the second half of next year, because right now the economy is pretty strong.

0:03:56

The consumer is in good health. Employment is very strong. Thank goodness that's something we're all worried about coming out of the pandemic. The corporate and the consumer balance sheets are strong. So we've got a lot of demand in the states. And I think that's going to take Mr. Powell, Chairman Powell, quite a challenge to get the painfully persistent inflation under

0:04:21
Alan Murray

control. Thank you for coming to inflation. You talked about the three R's, but we have the big I, inflation. Are we going to be able to get it under control without a serious recession?

0:04:30
Jane Fraser

I think we can get it under control without a serious recession coming through, partly because banks are in strong place. The consumer's got pretty strong health, same with corporate. So we're coming into it in a good place. But we do think that he's going to have to increase rates quite a bit more. He's going to have to keep them high for quite a long time to make sure that the inflation in services gets addressed because goods are coming off.

0:04:59

The goods inflation is really coming off quite quickly. It's all about services. What do you think? Do you have another question about inflation?

0:05:06
Ellen McGirt

You usually do.

0:05:07
Alan Murray

No, no, I'm waiting for you to liven this thing up.

0:05:11
Ellen McGirt

I was going to ask if I could renegotiate the interest rate on my Citi card. That's where I was going to take it. Jane, the last time I saw you, and I remember with such fondness, it was September 2019. Nobody knew what was coming. but we were having a conversation about gender and equity in the workplace. We were talking about women in finance. And it was also an opportunity for us to just go through your career at Citi.

0:05:38

You didn't grow up here like so many people did. You were a fully fledged adult when you got here, but you had some very, very big jobs. I'm looking through now, including running the private bank, U.S. consumer and commercial banking, and CEO of Latin America. So I'm curious about your transition to CEO at such a challenging time, but given what was already on your portfolio, how did you set your agenda going forward and looking back now?

0:06:02

Were you making the right steps?

0:06:03
Jane Fraser

We started off with vision, then moved to strategy, looking at talent and culture, and then what are the transformation we needed of our operations and risk and controls and others to support it. So possibly boringly textbook around that. But we started off with the vision for the bank. And then on to what does it mean for how we operate at the speed and scale and agility that a digital world demands.

0:06:32
Alan Murray

Can we dig down into the culture piece? Please. Would love to know. I mean, this was a turnaround job. It was considered a turnaround job. I think you saw it as a turnaround job. But you saw culture as key to getting the turnaround right. So what had to change and what did change in culture?

0:06:49
Jane Fraser

For me, it was also informed not only by what needed to change, it was also what was already strong in the bank, but then it was therefore very mindful of the environment. And there were really two E's that came to my mind as to what we want to be. We want to be known for excellence. It's a tangible bar, but it's a very important one. And in this type of world, very competitive, excellence is table stakes, I believe, in our industry.

0:07:18

But the one that for me was very important that I felt was already in the bank, but needed amplifying and needed amplifying in the industry was around empathy. And for me, empathy, we were at the time going through a human crisis, a health care crisis. So thinking about how do we make our people feel as comfortable as possible, not fearful for their health, also motivated to deliver for the communities they're operating in and for the clients who are going through very difficult times.

0:07:51

That was something that was important. And understanding what the client needs in this and really listening to them and being empathetic around that helps build a strong relationship, helps build very competitive solutions. So instead of selling what you want to sell, you're actually providing solutions for what a client needs.

0:08:16
Alan Murray

I'm pretty sure no one who held this position before you did or no one at the head of any of the major New York Citi banks has ever made empathy one of their key initiatives. Is it because you're a different person? Is it because this is a different time? Is it a combination of the two?

0:08:35
Jane Fraser

I think it's a combination of the two. I view empathy as a hard skill. It's not soft. This isn't about being nice. This gives you competitive edge. Empathy in our workforce has enabled us to attract and retain an extraordinarily diverse group of people in our organization. We've become an employer of choice. People want to work here because of the positions that we've taken. And so, no, I believe that empathy is about delivering excellence. It is about competitiveness.

0:09:13

It is about edge. I'm not sure that was a mindset that existed in the world a number of years ago. I think more and more leaders today are recognizing that that's the case.

0:09:24
Ellen McGirt

So does that mean that you're screening for talent or developing talent differently? If we look at empathy as a, thank you, she's nodding. If we're looking at empathy as a hard skill, listening, active listening is going to be part of it. Drawing together stakeholders, pulling together multiple solutions. You mentioned, it sounds like you're talking about co-creating solutions in a complicated world when there isn't an easy answer except a hammer or an axe.

0:09:49
Jane Fraser

I do think leadership and what you look for in your people has changed. And part of that's data. If we think back when, you know, Alan and I grew up all those years ago. Oh, God. We grew up in a world with more command and control. You just didn't have the amount of information available to everybody that we have today. Now as a leader, you don't have the answers. Your workforce has it. Your people have it.

0:10:16

And that's completely changed how you have to lead an organization. You have to unleash the creativity. You've got to make sure it's a collaborative environment. The innovation isn't happening because there's a genius at the top of the company that's coming up with the answers for everything other than in a very few handful of cases. And God bless them, but that's not what the rest of us are like. So it's really about, you know, how do you unleash this in an organization?

0:10:44

And you need collaboration. You need diversity. You need an environment where there's constructive challenge from everyone. And, you know, they're having at it, if needs be, until better ideas come through. That's very different from the more command and control followers that, you know, follow and do what they're told, as opposed to inspiring a group of innovators and making sure that they're all moving in the same direction. Very different. It's exciting, but we're certainly learning as we go on this one.

0:11:14
Alan Murray

So you were talking about culture. One of the great culture debates we've had in this Citi and in the world over the last year has been about, do we work together in an office or does everybody stay home in their jammies and do it from there? And it's been interesting to watch from here because right down the road, David Solomon, Goldman Sachs said a year ago, I want everybody back in the office. We're an in-office culture.

0:11:37

Jamie Dimon in the other direction at J.P. Morgan said, I want people who hustle, bring them all back in the office. And you said right off the bat, we're going to be a hybrid culture. So what was going through your mind as you were making that decision? Reality. It's not a commentary on the other two, I assume.

0:11:56
Jane Fraser

No, just in terms of what we were seeing in our own institution, listening to our people, but also seeing the reality of what was going on, which is, I still remember the day that we closed the books for the first time with not one person in a Citi office. And we closed a day ahead of when we normally do. What we saw and what we learned was that you didn't have to be in the office all the time.

0:12:21

So we took a step back and said, so we know that can work. But also, where is it that actually we are better when we're together? And we say, what was the why of why we do want people together part of the time? apprenticeship. And I think anyone who's been a working mum and dad recognised that homeschooling was challenging as opposed to when the kids are in the school. And there's value from them being together, the learning they get from the teachers.

0:12:49

You know, we may be a bit older, but it's not that different. There is a lot of value that you get from being together and some more of the spontaneity from that and the collaboration, the apprenticeship. So collaboration, apprenticeship, some of its productivity in certain areas. But for me, it's also a sense of belonging. We all felt that. It's lonely on your own. And the firms we work with, if you're proud of them, if you're proud of the job they're doing, it inspires a sense of belonging and a higher purpose for what you're doing every day rather than just going through a set of tasks.

0:13:26

But that being said, doesn't mean to say you've got to be there all the time. And some of the culture that I felt was a bit 1980s, frankly, was why do we need to have our junior bankers? They don't have to be in the office late at night if they're working on a deal. Once they've done the work collaborating together, they can do that at home. We know if they're doing a good job or not. And if they're not, the team's going to say, get back in the office and have those conversations.

0:13:58

But we honestly feel you can do both and be successful.

0:14:02
Alan Murray

Yeah. And so where have you ended up? I mean, how many days a week are people in the office

0:14:06
Jane Fraser

versus at home? It varies a bit by different jobs. So our traders tend to be here pretty well five days a week. They've got infrastructure at home. If there's a school play or something like that, that they want to run home at lunchtime so they can see the kids or other things like that. But typically they're here five days. Our call center staff are far less that way. They'll be coming in if they need training, if they're a poorer performer and they need some coaching from their manager and help them, and then they can go back home and working from home again.

0:14:40

So they're much more at home, probably coming in a couple of days a week. So it very much depends what job you're doing as to how often the majority of people were asking to come back two or three days a week and for the teams to work out which of those days make the most sense so they can be together. Let's face reality as well. It's a tight labor market out there. And so, you know, people tend to also vote with their feet on these ones.

0:15:14
Alan Murray

I'm here with Joe Yuccazoglu, the CEO of Deloitte U.S. and the sponsor of this podcast for all three of its seasons. Thank you for that, Joe. Pleasure to be here, Alan. Joe, we've had this rising talk about a notion of stakeholder capitalism, that businesses have a responsibility not just to their shareholders, but to their employees, to the communities they operate in, to the natural environment. Is all of that talk real and will it last, particularly when times get tough?

0:15:42
Speaker 4

I see a pretty durable shift, Alan, with a lot of momentum here. CEOs are prioritizing sustainability. They're prioritizing purpose. They're prioritizing trust. You certainly see some noise. On one end, there's some skepticism as to whether this is virtue signaling. On the other end, there's some lingering debate about whether this broader focus on stakeholders detracts from shareholder returns. If you cut through all the noise, what we're seeing is actually a huge convergence of interests. This is core to sustaining a vibrant capitalist system.

0:16:16

If you take a long-term view, the only way that you're going to deliver sustainable shareholder returns is to take really good care of all of those constituents that you referenced. And is it working, Joe? Well, business was at the heart of leading society through the pandemic. Business is at the heart of addressing the climate challenge. We're seeing massive momentum with very tangible commitments and tangible actions towards decarbonizing the economy. So, yes, I think the evidence is ample.

0:16:44

Joe, thank you. Alan, it's a real pleasure.

0:16:51
Ellen McGirt

you came into the ceo role with an advantage of some of your peers and that you had already thought deeply and thoroughly about equity and diversity and inclusion issues it was something you were already fluent in that language and you thought a lot about it and you were in a position to advise on a lot of it how is that work going how are you meeting your targets and what new targets have you

0:17:13
Jane Fraser

set? We set some targets. So Mike Corbett, my predecessor, was really strong on this. He really felt this mattered. And I think he set most of this in motion. And we've been building upon the tone he set, which is a wonderful position to be in. So Mike had set three-year goals. We met them in terms of representation. In fact, we exceeded them by a bit, which is always good. and that was on gender representation. So effectively, we looked at the 100 ,000 of our 220 ,000 roles that we have at Citi.

0:17:49

We wanted 40 % or above to be helped by women for the 100 ,000 most senior roles. And we exceeded that target. And we measure it at every single level in every single geography. and we look at recruiting, we look at metrics around retention, development and promotion in each of those. We manage the processes around it to try and make sure that we provide everyone with the opportunities that they deserve. But it takes a lot of work to get the inclusion to work and make sure people are playing to that.

0:18:28

Similarly, with our black colleagues in the States, that we set a target. We exceeded it. It's not a huge target. And we have clearly more work to do there going forward as we do on all fronts. We've then extended those to more representation globally beyond gender and set targets. We've done the same for more groups beyond just our black colleagues and our female colleagues. And we've done so for the next three years of targets. you've made them public.

0:18:58

You need to get comfortable with the uncomfortable. Transparency works. Making those commitments public definitely helps as a forcing device that we all need so you don't slip. And the other area that we've put in place has been pay equity, which again, we publish. We measure for every single job in the firm every year. And every year we do have to make a small adjustment to that because there are biases in the system and the like. And we do that.

0:19:30

We have a third party do the measurement. And we publish externally what is our adjusted pay gap, but then what the raw pay gap is. And that raw pay gap shows that we still have to get more women into more senior roles and into more high paying roles. And every year we try and

0:19:49
Ellen McGirt

make that move further forward. How I knew that you were, as an organization, taking this seriously is I was invited to an HBCU internship recruitment event. And I was astonished at the level of executive involvement, people who came and spoke, and also that you had a differentiated strategy per college, per university. Each one had its own recruiting strategy, which is something I had never considered before. And HBCU is not a monolith. Women are not a monolith.

0:20:19

You know, they're coming from communities or coming from backgrounds. That I thought was really powerful.

0:20:24
Jane Fraser

One of the points you're raising up is a very important one. We look at this across all of our diversity and inclusion efforts. We look at it also in our ESG agenda. This has to become part of the bank. It's not a layer that sits above. It has to get embedded into how you do business. I can run through many, many different efforts, but when you know that you're going to make it sustainable is only if you make it part of how the bank operates every day rather than being something special.

0:20:54
Alan Murray

You took this job at a time when companies were really rethinking their role in society, and diversity and inclusion was certainly a big part of that. But it also was around climate. You had a big rise in ESG investing. You had a big rise in companies making net zero commitments. Now we're seeing pushback. The governor of Florida, who may well be the Republican nominee for president at this point, is attacking companies that adopt ESG as being woke corporations and saying that they should focus on making profits for their shareholders.

0:21:29

You see that line being picked up by others. What's your response to that? Oh, this is not mutually exclusive.

0:21:37
Jane Fraser

I think we firmly believe that you can responsibly serve your shareholders at the same time as looking at the needs of other stakeholders and that there's a big concentric circle there. Let's take energy and let's go back to empathy again. As we sat down and looked at climate, and we talked to our clients, whether it was users or producers of energy, they all need help with the transition. It is not an easy transition. And this country is going to be the country that will be the one that comes up with the new sustainable energy technologies, the carbon capture at scale, and a cost that can be afforded because we came up with the vaccine in extraordinary time.

0:22:25

We came up with the shale oil and gas technologies and capabilities out of the private sector. Never don't bet on the American entrepreneur. It's a thing of extraordinary. So when we listen to our clients, they want to have cleaner energy. They want to transition to this. they want to ensure there is an energy security. We've got to work on the how. So for our bank, and I think many of our peers, we're focused on both. We don't see them as being mutually exclusive, and it's not changed what we're trying to do.

0:23:04

Because the reality is, there's a lot of problems to be solved, and let's get on with tackling them and get them solved and get to

0:23:13
Alan Murray

the win-win. That's very practical and sensible and pragmatic, but you're living in a political world where people don't seem to be particularly practical or sensible or pragmatic. They want to pull us apart. And so either you're for drill baby drill or you're a woke clean energy. You're a regulated industry. You have to live in the middle of all that politics. How do you deal

0:23:34
Jane Fraser

with it? I believe it's just called getting on with the day job. It's noise versus signal. Our day job is to help support our clients, both transitioning and also producing the energy that's needed as cleanly as possible, but without blowing up communities and without changing what's going on. I grew up in a town that saw manufacturing move from that town to Asia and saw coal mines locally get shut down. But there was a very good public-private partnership that helped with a lot of skill reinvestment, that eased unemployment, that really reinvented those communities.

0:24:14

We've got to look at how do we do that. And I think, again, this is where these points of empathy become so important. we've got to do all of it. But how do we do that? We get on with it.

0:24:26
Ellen McGirt

All right. The flip side, not the flip side, but another way to tackle that issue, Alan, which I think is so important, we all think about the division, is that when your bank says something's important, you kind of have to pay attention to it. And I think increasingly, we're going to see interesting restrictions for lending to properties that don't have environmental protections in place. In a way that goes around kind of the political divide, you're setting standards for people if you want to do business with us.

0:24:52

And if you want to borrow money at a reasonable rate, you're going to need to conduct your business in a certain way. I think that's part of it too. If you say it's important, it's important.

0:25:01
Jane Fraser

And we take that responsibility very seriously. We don't make decisions based on political perspectives. As a CEO, I move my own personal opinions to the side because they're not relevant. And what's important is what do our clients need? What do our people need and say? And what do they care about? As a bank that works in almost 100 countries around the world and has done in most of those countries for over a century, we've seen the good, bad and ugly.

0:25:33

And we have a pretty good handle on how is it that you try and push for progress in a way that's socially responsible, but also puts the shareholder at front and center there. And we generally do find that there is a way to do that and get on with it.

0:25:52
Ellen McGirt

God, when I don't know what to do, when I'm stuck on a story, I'm just going to hear Gene's voice say, just get on with it.

0:25:57
Alan Murray

Get on with it. And file that story to your editor. Can we talk about crypto? Because it's this sort of massive 1 trillion dollar financial business that's grown up alongside yours. And then we just recently had the meltdown of one of the biggest platforms that people were trading on, FTX. What effect does all that have on your business and on the economy generally?

0:26:19
Jane Fraser

I'm pausing because a lot of the technologies, blockchain in particular, and others have tremendous promise. And they have an ability to help manage risk better, to help manage efficiency, more tools to drive inclusion, and a range of other pieces. However, you have to have a framework which provides investor protection, provides protection against financial crimes, fraud, as well as money laundering and theft, as well as consumer protections around the fees that are charged, around bankruptcy and other areas like that.

0:27:03

Right now, we have this parallel ecosystem that's developed that does not have that. And that, as a banker, is very worrying. And we need those guardrails because left unfettered, bad things happen. And I think that's why you've seen all of the large banks, I believe I can speak for my peers and the institutions they represent, we haven't been at the forefront of providing these products because without those guardrails around, we're very concerned about it. So you've seen us investing in the technologies, underpinning it, but you have not seen material engagement with the products because we believe firmly we need to have the investor protections in particular because grandma is investing in crypto.

0:27:58

If grandma's investing in crypto, we better have protections in place. It's different if you're a highly sophisticated investor, if you're someone who's got a family office around them, etc. That's different. But I think it's absolutely imperative that we get that right. And that's why you've seen the banking sector holding back from being aggressive in this area because we recognize the need to have those guardrails in place.

0:28:27
Alan Murray

You know, we at Fortune celebrate the women who have made it to the top of business organizations. We have for 25 years. Ellen's been a big part of building that community and you've been part of that community. But I have to say one of the things I've heard many times in interviews with the women who have made it to the top is a sense that they felt they had to work harder than anyone else in the room.

0:28:49

You know, they had to double down. They couldn't afford to take time off in their careers. They just went, went, went. And either they needed an incredibly supportive ecosystem or they made the decision not to have children, whatever. You are different in the sense that you actively stepped back at one point in your career and said, I'm going to focus for now. I'm going to focus on my family. How did you do that? And do you think other women can do that now?

0:29:13
Jane Fraser

Well, I hope I can make you blush to start off with, too, Alan, because Fortune was incredibly supportive of me. The community of women from the most powerful women and all of the effort and thought that goes behind it, for me, felt like a warm embrace and was one of the reasons I actively moved from the UK to the US because I felt this would be an ecosystem that would be more supportive of senior female leaders.

0:29:43

I was right. And Fortune was genuinely an important part of that. Early on, an extraordinary network. It made a huge difference. And you're right, you need that supportive environment. My husband was also incredibly supportive of me. And he had a big and serious career. And he always made me feel as if we would be a collaborative team, a win-win around it. I also worked for a firm, this was McKinsey when I moved part-time as a partner, right when I made partner, and they supported me

0:30:20
Alan Murray

for five years or so of working part-time. Even though people told you don't have kids while you're up for a partner, right? You were told that's not the way to get ahead at McKinsey.

0:30:31
Jane Fraser

A couple of people made that point, but you just say, this is what's important for me. And I think I was in an environment where I felt I could be courageous around that. And I could say, no, if I don't have what I need personally, the professional side won't work either. And for me, it was really important. I wanted to be a mum who was around for the kids at the point where they were younger and little and they needed me around.

0:31:02

And that was really important for me. And I had to have some courage to do that for sure. I also had to park my own ego as some of the people who used to work for me started becoming more senior than me. And I had to be real that that was my own ego that was a bit more of the issue there than anything else. So there were a few hard truths in this one. And frankly, if I hadn't done that, I wouldn't be in the seat I'm in today.

0:31:28

So sometimes these tough calls you make are the ones that actually enable you in the long run to be successful.

0:31:34
Ellen McGirt

That is a really beautiful story. And I think where MPW has grown, Most Powerful Women has grown, is outside of who looked like a corporate person or a female version of a corporate acceptable person to being all kinds of people in all kinds of bodies with all kinds of hair, some of which is federally protected in the Crown Act, of course. How do you think about, I know you think a lot about gender, how do you think about the intersectional nature of inclusion going forward, particularly for majority culture women who have succeeded and who now need to think more seriously or in a more structured way about bringing everybody along?

0:32:11
Jane Fraser

It can't be a zero-sum game because if it's a zero-sum game, it really gets frictions into it. And I think that takes some work around the business case. And it also takes some time and proof points. I give you one example. In our healthcare program, our gay community came to us, our LBGTQ, and said, and I remember it was one of our wonderful heads of that group. he came and said, our healthcare program doesn't provide healthcare benefits for partners, either in countries where gay marriage is not allowed, even where it is.

0:32:49

So we said, well, that's crazy. And we made sure that it was available for everybody. Well, it lifted everybody up. The majority of people who applied for that program were unmarried couples who were living together. And ironically, it brought down the cost of health care for everybody in the institution. So these are examples of cases where you can lift everybody up by these actions of having a more inclusive environment. And we're finding more and more of those proof points that demonstrate that this does make us more competitive in the talent market.

0:33:29

So when you put all the pieces together,

0:33:31
Alan Murray

This was a turnaround job. Citi had had regulatory problems, probably had some cultural problems that you were trying to address. It's a big institution. These are hard, hard jobs. If you sort of look at a scale of one to 10, where one is where you started and 10 is where you want to end up, where are you now?

0:33:50
Jane Fraser

I think with all transformations, it's a multi-year journey. So we're certainly, you know, we're down the path, but we're, you know, we've got a ways to go. we're making really good progress. We're approaching this with urgency, with determination. We know where we need to get to because we started with that vision, the strategy, the culture, and then the plans. Everyone's going through a transformation at the moment because the digital world is changing in every single industry that's out there.

0:34:21

And all the societal things we talked about today, everyone's going through a transformation. So we're not going through it alone. But I don't pretend that ours isn't a material one. This is a makeover of an institution leveraging our strengths and the extraordinary history that we've got, but also making sure that we're really in a position to win for the digital decade ahead. And we'll do so with excellence. We'll do so with excellency. And we'll do so with urgency and determination.

0:34:53
Alan Murray

Wow, that sounded like an ending, Ellen. Oh, it sure did.

0:34:56
Jane Fraser

She wants to get on with her day.

0:34:58
Alan Murray

Thank you so much for spending the time to talk with us. Really fascinating. Great to be here with you.

0:35:03
Jane Fraser

Thank you very much indeed. Thank you both.

0:35:11
Alan Murray

Leadership Next is edited by Alexis Haught. Written by me, Alan Murray, along with my amazing colleagues, Ellen McGirt and Megan Arnold. Our theme is by Jason Snell, executive producer, Megan Arnold. Leadership Next is a production of Fortune Media. Leadership Next episodes are produced by Fortune's editorial team. The views and opinions expressed by podcast speakers and guests are solely their own and do not reflect the opinions of Deloitte or its personnel, nor does Deloitte advocate or endorse any individuals or entities featured on the episodes.