In brief
TSMC dominates chipmaking because it pioneered the foundry model, in which a company only manufactures chips and never designs them. Tim Culpan argues the company grew out of Taiwan's state-backed industrial policy and an American-style management culture. Years of heavy spending on equipment and engineers created an advantage that rivals, and even rich governments, struggle to copy with money alone.
The central tension is that TSMC wants to stay neutral between the US and China but is likely to be forced to pick a side. Culpan expects it to choose America. Its other vulnerabilities are being too advanced for customers to need, a deep tech downturn, and Taiwan's power shortage. Meanwhile China and the US try to build rival chip industries from scratch.
Questions
Why is TSMC so important to the world economy?
Tim Culpan says almost every electronic device, from iPhones and cars to temperature sensors, contains a TSMC chip somewhere. He believes the global technology industry would grind to a halt very quickly if TSMC stopped production.
What is the foundry model and why did it matter?
A foundry only manufactures chips for other companies that design them, instead of doing both jobs itself. It let anyone start a chip design company without building factories, which is how firms like Qualcomm grew.
Is TSMC a Taiwanese or an American company at heart?
Culpan argues its roots and culture are far more American than Chinese. Its two chairmen have been American citizens, its governance style is American, and its biggest paying customers are American.
Can TSMC stay neutral between the US and China?
Culpan thinks not forever. He points to the US effectively telling TSMC to stop making chips for Huawei, and says that when forced to choose it will pick the American side.
What could knock TSMC off the top?
Culpan lists three risks: its technology getting so good that customers stop paying for the newest generation, a huge tech slowdown, and Taiwan's electricity shortage. He also says Samsung is the only other company that might overtake it.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company was founded by Morris Chang in 1987, roughly 14 or 15 years after the seeds of Taiwan's semiconductor industry were planted.
“It was founded by Maurice Jiang himself back in 1987, but the seeds of Taiwan's Semiconductor industry predated that by about 14 or 15 years”
0:06:19 · Tim Culpan · TSMC founding · 1987
The Taiwan government set up the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI) in 1973 to build technology industries.
“when an organization was set up by the Taiwan government back then in 1973 called ITRI, the Industrial Technology Research Institute.”
0:06:19 · Tim Culpan · ITRI · 1973
AMD's Jerry Sanders later said the famous line that 'real men have fabs', reflecting the view that chip companies should manufacture their own chips.
“at the time, Jerry Sanders of AMD later said in that famous line that real men have fabs.”
0:08:11 · Tim Culpan · Chip industry
Morris Chang was born in China and left in 1948 during the Civil War, according to Tim Culpan.
“He was born in China and left China at the height of the Civil War in 1948.”
0:09:52 · Tim Culpan · Morris Chang · 1948
Morris Chang moved to Taiwan at age 54 to take up a job at ITRI.
“who went to Taiwan at the ripe old age of 54 to take up a retirement job.”
0:09:52 · Tim Culpan · Morris Chang
Philips was a founding investor in TSMC with a stake Tim Culpan recalls as about 30 percent.
“Philips was actually a founding investor and had, I think it was about 30 % stake.”
0:12:17 · Tim Culpan · TSMC investors
United Microelectronics (UMC) was spun out of ITRI around 1980.
“but born out of ITRI in around 1980 was another company called UMC, United Microelectronics.”
0:16:59 · Tim Culpan · UMC · 1980
MediaTek was spun out of UMC in the late 1990s.
“it then spun out of UMC in the late 90s was a company called MediaTek”
0:16:59 · Tim Culpan · MediaTek · 1990s
Singapore-based Chartered was an early foundry rival to TSMC that eventually could not keep up.
“There was a company called Chartered that was also looking quite strong for a while until they just couldn't keep up with TSMC.”
0:17:37 · Tim Culpan · Foundry competition
Tim Culpan says TSMC's costs are mostly depreciation on equipment, with spending of roughly $10 to $20 billion a year.
“the cost base for the TSMC model is it's mostly depreciation. You spend buckets of money, $10 or $20 billion a year at the current rate”
0:18:41 · Tim Culpan · TSMC costs · 2021
Foxconn started out making basic plastic TV knobs, according to Tim Culpan.
“And Foxconn, which was getting going at around about the same time, started off making basic plastic TV knobs.”
0:08:54 · Tim Culpan · Foxconn · 1980s
Tim Culpan says TSMC's two chairmen, Morris Chang and Mark Liu, have both been American citizens.
“The two people who've held the chairmanship of TSMC are both American citizens.”
0:24:39 · Tim Culpan · TSMC leadership
As of January 2021, Tim Culpan estimated 95 to 98 percent of TSMC's production capacity was in Taiwan.
“As of right now, you know, January 2021, like 95 % or probably 98 % of their production capacity is in Taiwan.”
0:26:12 · Tim Culpan · TSMC capacity · 2021
Tim Culpan says the US effectively told TSMC to stop making chips for Huawei, and TSMC had to comply.
“the US basically said almost directly to TSMC without naming, like, you shall not make chips for Huawei anymore.”
0:28:21 · Tim Culpan · Huawei restrictions · 2020
Tim Culpan says very few companies can afford EUV chipmaking equipment and also have the staff and processes to run it.
“there's very very few companies that can a afford to buy this euv equipment and b have the know-how including the staff and the processes to run it”
0:33:16 · Tim Culpan · EUV equipment · 2021
Tim Culpan names Samsung as the only other company likely to overtake TSMC, noting they were neck and neck for a while.
“And Samsung is a very, very strong competitor. And they were neck and neck for a while.”
0:35:05 · Tim Culpan · Samsung competition
Tim Culpan says Taiwan has a power problem as it begins shutting down nuclear power stations, which threatens energy-hungry chip factories.
“And Taiwan actually has a power problem. Taiwan, for political reasons, is starting to shut down its nuclear power stations.”
0:38:12 · Tim Culpan · Taiwan power · 2021
Tim Culpan says more silicon is made in Arizona, where Intel has a factory, than in California.
“In fact, there's more silicon made in Arizona where Intel has a factory than is made in California.”
0:45:24 · Tim Culpan · US chipmaking · 2021
Tim Culpan says China's SMIC is still struggling to get close to TSMC's capabilities.
“SMIC, Semiconductor Manufacturing International, which is kind of, I guess, the most famous of the flag bearers in China, is really still struggling to get close to a company like TSMC.”
0:44:51 · Tim Culpan · China chips · 2021
Joe Weisenthal says TSMC was worth nearly $600 to $700 billion at the time of recording.
“And I think it's now a 600 or 700 billion dollar company almost, which puts it in league with some of the real, you know, huge tech winners.”
0:50:22 · Joe Weisenthal · TSMC valuation · 2021
Joe Weisenthal says automakers faced chip shortages because chipmakers cut automotive chip production during the spring 2020 crisis.
“car manufacturers around the world are actually running into supply constraints because they can't get chips because the chip manufacturers decided to reduce their production of automotive chips during the crisis in the spring”
0:03:20 · Joe Weisenthal · Auto chip shortage · 2020