In brief
Kishore Mahbubani argues that Asia, and especially Southeast Asia and India, now has far more weight in world affairs than the West tends to admit. He says Asean has been more successful than the European Union, India is rising fast, and Europe must accept a smaller role. He also warns that nobody should write off the United States.
The main tension is between rising Asian power and the stubborn strength of the US. Mahbubani sees US-China rivalry intensifying under either presidential candidate, but thinks war over Taiwan is unlikely unless Taiwan declares independence. He expects Kamala Harris to be predictable and Donald Trump to be unpredictable, and says the world order must adjust to big shifts in power.
Questions
Why does Kishore Mahbubani say Asean is more successful than the European Union?
He says no country has left Asean, whereas the UK left the EU in Brexit, and Asean has helped prevent wars nearby while the EU failed to stop the war in Ukraine. He also points to its ability to draw leaders from many major powers to its yearly summits.
Will China invade Taiwan, according to this episode?
Mahbubani says he is very confident China will not invade unless Taiwan declares independence. He argues that China follows Sun Tzu's idea of winning without fighting and believes time is on its side.
Is the United States really in decline?
Mahbubani calls talk of US decline definitely premature. He points to American universities and to the US making the key breakthroughs in artificial intelligence, even though many had predicted China would win that race.
How would a Harris or Trump presidency change US policy toward China?
Mahbubani says pressure on China will grow under either one, because Washington broadly believes it has about ten years to stop China becoming number one. He expects Harris to be more careful, while he says Trump cannot be predicted and might back Taiwan strongly or treat it as a liability.
Why does he want the UK to give up its UN Security Council seat?
He argues the veto was meant for the great powers of today, not of yesterday, and that the UK no longer qualifies. He says India, already a top-five economy and heading for third place by 2030, should take the seat.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Kishore Mahbubani was twice Singapore's ambassador to the United Nations and served as president of the UN Security Council in January 2001 and May 2002.
“he was twice Singapore's ambassador to the UN and president of the UN Security Council in January 2001 and May 2002.”
0:00:01 · Nirmal Ghosh · Diplomatic career · 2001
Kishore Mahbubani was permanent secretary at Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and founding dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy.
“He has also been permanent secretary at Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, founding dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy”
0:00:44 · Nirmal Ghosh · Career
Kishore Mahbubani says the United States and Soviet Union during the Cold War lived in separate universes with little direct contact, unlike the US and China today.
“the United States and the Soviet Union lived in two distinct universes without any sort of direct contact with each other.”
0:03:37 · Kishore Mahbubani · Cold War
Kishore Mahbubani says China is already the world's biggest economy in purchasing power parity terms.
“Now, it is already the world's biggest economy in purchasing power parity terms, PPP.”
0:05:10 · Kishore Mahbubani · Chinese economy
Kishore Mahbubani says that in 2000 Japan was the world's second-largest economy and eight times bigger than Asean's combined economy.
“Number one, in the year 2000, Japan was the world's second largest economy, right? Far ahead of China, far bigger and eight times bigger than ASEAN.”
0:07:02 · Kishore Mahbubani · Asean economy · 2000
Kishore Mahbubani says Japan's economy is now only 1.2 to 1.3 times Asean's and that Asean will be bigger than Japan by 2030.
“But now Japan is only 1.2, 1.3 times bigger. And by 2030, ASEAN will be bigger than Japan.”
0:07:02 · Kishore Mahbubani · Asean economy · 2030
Kishore Mahbubani says Asean added more to global economic growth than the European Union from 2010 to 2020, despite having an economy about one-fifth the size.
“ASEAN added more to global economic growth from 2010 to 2020 than the European Union did.”
0:07:38 · Kishore Mahbubani · Economic growth · 2010-2020
Kishore Mahbubani says leaders from the United States, Russia, the European Union, Japan, India, Australia, New Zealand and South Korea attend the annual East Asia Summit alongside Asean.
“leaders from the United States, Russia, European Union, Japan, India, Australia, New Zealand, South Korea, all come.”
0:06:20 · Kishore Mahbubani · Asean summits
Kishore Mahbubani says India is already a top-five economy and will become the world's third-largest by 2030.
“India, which is already the top five economy in the world, is going to become number three by 2030.”
0:09:28 · Kishore Mahbubani · Indian economy · 2030
Kishore Mahbubani says that a few years earlier many predicted China would win the AI race because of its larger data pools, but the US made the key breakthroughs.
“I remember three to four years ago, everyone would say China will definitely win the race for AI because China's got much larger pools of data”
0:12:50 · Kishore Mahbubani · Artificial intelligence
Kishore Mahbubani says Henry Kissinger's book on China notes that the Chinese accept Sun Tzu's maxim that the best way to win a war is to win it without fighting.
“he points out that the Chinese have always accepted this maxim of Sun Tzu, which is that the best way to win a war is to win it by not fighting.”
0:14:47 · Kishore Mahbubani · Chinese strategy
Kishore Mahbubani says Taiwan's passport is accepted in roughly 180 to 190 countries even though Taiwan is not a UN member.
“your passport is accepted in, I don't know, 180, 190 countries in the world.”
0:15:28 · Kishore Mahbubani · Taiwan passport
Kishore Mahbubani says there is a near-universal consensus in Washington that the US has about ten years to stop China becoming number one.
“a near universal consensus in Washington, D.C. that the U.S. has about 10 years to stop China from becoming number one.”
0:16:54 · Kishore Mahbubani · US China policy
Kishore Mahbubani says the US has tried tariffs and the CHIPS Act to hold back China, and that tariffs have not worked.
“And the United States establishment, they've already tried tariffs on China, which haven't worked. They tried CHIPS Act.”
0:16:54 · Kishore Mahbubani · US China policy
Kishore Mahbubani says Mike Pompeo, after leaving office as US Secretary of State, gave a speech in Taiwan saying the US should recognise Taiwan as an independent country.
“Mike Pompeo, after he stepped down as Secretary of State, went to Taiwan and gave a speech saying, United States should recognize Taiwan as an independent country.”
0:18:34 · Kishore Mahbubani · Taiwan policy
Kishore Mahbubani says the Biden administration began by aiming to isolate China but turned more realistic after two or three years, with relations stabilising by its fourth year.
“the Biden administration started in a very gung-ho basis, saying, hey, we will isolate China.”
0:18:01 · Kishore Mahbubani · Biden China policy · 2021-2024
Kishore Mahbubani says about 300 million Indians were ruled by roughly 100,000 Englishmen a century ago.
“300 million of your ancestors, my ancestors in India, were effortlessly ruled by 100,000 Englishmen.”
0:19:54 · Kishore Mahbubani · British Empire
Kishore Mahbubani says the EU's combined economy was ten times China's in 1980 and is about the same size today.
“In the year 1980, Europe's economy in combined EU, GNP, was 10 times the size of China, 10 times. Today, they're about the same size.”
0:20:34 · Kishore Mahbubani · European economy · 1980
Kishore Mahbubani predicts that by 2050 Europe's economy will be half the size of China's.
“By 2050, Europe will be half the size of China.”
0:20:34 · Kishore Mahbubani · European economy · 2050