In brief
Brian Brooks, then Acting Comptroller of the Currency, argues that banking activity is leaking out of banks into fintech and crypto firms that regulators cannot see. His proposed fix is to open the national bank charter to payments and lending companies, even if they take no deposits, so the OCC can keep supervising safety and soundness. He says regulators should build frameworks, not pick technologies.
The central tension is between short-term crisis and long-term modernization. Brooks says the pandemic shock is manageable for now but could worsen if the economy stays shut, while it also speeds the move to digital finance. He pairs optimism about AI, crypto and fintech inclusion with worries about remote supervision, data ownership, middle-sized banks falling behind, and the court fight over fintech charters.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
In his first months as Acting Comptroller of the Currency, Brian Brooks approved the first national charter for a fintech organization and suggested a federal payments charter.
“Brooks has already made statements regarding the role of banking organizations in supporting communities, approved the first national charter to a fintech organization, and suggested a federal payments charter.”
0:00:13 · Jim Marous · OCC charters · 2020
Brian Brooks previously worked at OneWest Bank, served on the board of Fannie Mae, and was chief legal officer at Coinbase.
“Brooks' background includes roles at OneWest Bank, the board at Fannie Mae, and his chief legal officer at Coinbase.”
0:00:42 · Jim Marous · Brooks background
Brooks says OCC examiners have told him that many of the greatest bank frauds were uncovered by examiners noticing inconsistencies in meetings, which makes remote examination riskier.
“many of the greatest bank frauds in history weren't discovered based on management reports or slide decks to the board.”
0:05:22 · Brian Brooks · Bank examination · 2020
Brooks said OCC data showed about 22 percent of pandemic relief dollars were still unspent in deposit accounts, which he read as a month or two of runway.
“Now, there's less than there was, but about 22 % of those dollars are still sitting in deposit accounts, which tells me we've got another month or two of runway before things get dire.”
0:09:19 · Brian Brooks · Pandemic deposits · 2020
Brooks said the best credit underwriting models capture only about 65 percent of loan performance.
“The best models are only capturing about 65 % of performance.”
0:11:22 · Brian Brooks · Credit models · 2020
Brooks said about 45 million Americans have no credit score, disproportionately people of color, which he argued AI-based underwriting could help address.
“there are 45 million Americans, disproportionately many of them people of color, who don't have a credit score.”
0:12:47 · Brian Brooks · Credit scores · 2020
Brooks said he welcomed the Federal Reserve's advance notice of proposed rulemaking on the Community Reinvestment Act and was open to reopening the issue.
“And that's why I've welcomed the Federal Reserve's ANPR on this issue. We'll learn stuff next year.”
0:17:42 · Brian Brooks · CRA reform · 2020
Brooks pointed to Square at coffee shops and Stripe for internet businesses as examples of customers choosing fintech payment processors over banks.
“Why does every coffee shop in America choose to use Square as their payment processor as opposed to a bank? Why does every internet business want to use Stripe instead of a bank?”
0:19:11 · Brian Brooks · Fintech payments · 2020
Brooks said investors were giving about 15x multiples to big bank stocks and about 50x multiples to fintech valuations.
“They're giving 15x multiples on big bank stocks, and they're giving 50x multiples on fintech valuations.”
0:19:37 · Brian Brooks · Valuations · 2020
Brooks served on the board of Avant, a large online lender, before his time at Coinbase.
“I was on the board of one of the biggest internet lenders, a company called Avant.”
0:21:05 · Brian Brooks · Brooks background
Brooks said America has more than 6,000 banks that all focus on the same 75 to 80 percent of the market, leaving a gap that fintech filled.
“we have more than 6 ,000 banks in America, and they're all focused on the same 75 % or 80 % of the market.”
0:21:26 · Brian Brooks · Bank market · 2020
Brooks said about 15 years earlier roughly 50 to 60 percent of US consumer lending happened inside banks, before moving to non-bank platforms.
“Even if you went back 15 years, something like 50 or 60 % of consumer lending in America happened inside of banks.”
0:24:17 · Brian Brooks · Consumer lending · 2005
Brooks argued that because the OCC can only supervise deposit-taking companies, lending and payments leaving that group creates a choice between reimagining the charter and accepting unsupervised risk.
“if the only kind of company that I can supervise is a company that takes deposits, and those businesses are leaving the depository universe for the non-depository universe, then we have a choice.”
0:25:07 · Brian Brooks · Charter reform · 2020
Brooks said many core processor contracts state that transaction data on their platforms belongs to the processor rather than the bank.
“Under their contracts, though, a lot of these contracts say that the transactional data generated on their platforms belongs to them and not the bank.”
0:28:06 · Brian Brooks · Core processors · 2020
Brooks said one could rationalize US bank regulation into the OCC as supervisor, the FDIC for deposit insurance and resolution, and the Federal Reserve for monetary policy.
“you can imagine a world where we had one supervision agency, and that would be the OCC. We have one deposit insurance and resolution agency, that would be the FDIC.”
0:30:57 · Brian Brooks · Regulatory structure · 2020
Brooks said the OCC regulates essentially all of the largest US banks, with the vast majority of banking assets in its system.
“I regulate essentially all of the biggest banks and a lot of small banks too, don't get me wrong, but the vast majority of banking assets are in the OCC system”
0:31:20 · Brian Brooks · OCC scope · 2020
Brooks said almost 50 million Americans own crypto, about as many as use Uber.
“there are almost 50 million Americans who own crypto. This is not a niche thing. There are as many Americans who own crypto as use Uber.”
0:33:11 · Brian Brooks · Crypto adoption · 2020
Brooks described Bitcoin and other blockchains as public ledgers that validate who owes what to whom, which is a function banks perform.
“Basically, the Bitcoin blockchain and other blockchains are doing what banks do. They're a ledger of transactions that are validating who owes what to whom”
0:34:36 · Brian Brooks · Blockchain
The OCC issued a letter allowing banks to provide crypto custody services and a second letter about stablecoins, which Brooks framed as part of treating blockchains as payment systems.
“you mentioned our custody letter, we also have a second letter about stable coins, is that we believe that one way of thinking about these blockchain networks is their payment systems.”
0:35:06 · Brian Brooks · OCC crypto letters · 2020
Brooks noted that national banks were already authorized to hold assets such as gold bullion, fine wines and antique art in custody before the crypto custody letter.
“We've authorized them to hold gold bullion and fine wines and antique art and things like that.”
0:37:22 · Brian Brooks · Bank custody
Brooks argued that other countries are using blockchain, stablecoins and central bank digital currencies to compete with the US dollar.
“Other countries are focused on blockchain and stablecoin and central bank digital currencies as a way of competing with the dollar.”
0:37:46 · Brian Brooks · Dollar competitiveness · 2020
The OCC regulates national banks, savings associations and foreign bank branches, including the Bank of China.
“we regulate national banks, we regulate savings associations, but we also regulate foreign branches. So there are a number of companies, the Bank of China would be an example of one”
0:39:04 · Brian Brooks · OCC jurisdiction · 2020
Brooks predicted that mid-sized regional banks will narrow their services, outsource other functions and possibly sell business lines.
“Those companies, I think, are going to ultimately sort of skinny down their suite of services to focus on what they're best at, and they'll outsource a lot of other things.”
0:42:04 · Brian Brooks · Regional banks