In brief
Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu argues that crypto is not inevitable and that regulators and the public should decide now what they want from it. He treats stablecoins as the foundation of the crypto system. In his view, three choices (how stable, how interoperable and how separable from banking they should be) should be settled early, so that innovators can build within them and regulators stop chasing each new product.
The main tension is between innovation and protection. Crypto promises inclusion and lower costs, but it also brings volatility, scams, irreversible transactions and weak consumer recourse. Hsu says regulators must look at the big picture and the details at once. They should favor stability for money-like products and leave room for innovation elsewhere. He also warns that blockchain technology has built-in trade-offs, and that a community-driven culture may sit on top of very transactional technology.
Questions
What is a stablecoin and why do regulators care so much about them?
A stablecoin is a crypto token meant to hold a steady value, such as one US dollar. Hsu says about $180 billion of them supports the whole crypto market, so a failure could hurt many people and weaken the dollar's role.
Should stablecoin issuers have to be regulated like banks?
Hsu says there are two models: a disclosure-based one like money market funds, and a bank-style prudential one. He argues the bank approach is more stable, and notes that a presidential working group report also leaned that way. The exact setup may need new legislation.
Why can't one stablecoin or blockchain just work with another?
Hsu says today's stablecoins like Tether and USD Coin are separate and must be traded to move between them. Blockchains such as Ethereum and Solana use different code, and the bridges linking them are fragile and have been hacked.
What is the blockchain trilemma?
Hsu cites Vitalik Buterin's idea that a blockchain can have only two of three qualities: decentralization, security and scalability. Ethereum is decentralized and secure but struggles to scale, while Solana gives up some decentralization to scale.
Is crypto good or bad for lower-income and minority consumers?
Hsu says both are true. Crypto appeals to groups that traditional banking has often failed, and it is disproportionately held by younger, diverse and underbanked people. But it is volatile and full of scams, so he wants opportunity and protection together.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency was established during the U.S. Civil War to bring order to a money supply made up of privately issued banknotes.
“Its arcane-sounding name arises from the fact that it was established during the U.S. Civil War to literally get control over the currency at a chaotic time when money consisted of privately issued banknotes.”
0:07:45 · Jo Ann Barefoot · OCC history · U.S. Civil War
In March 2022 President Joe Biden issued an executive order on crypto assets that called on multiple agencies to develop strategies balancing benefits and risks.
“that framing has shifted in March when President Biden issued an executive order on the topic.”
0:01:34 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Executive order · 2022
Michael Hsu says derivatives, once promoted as a way to hedge risk and lower credit costs, got out of control and contributed to the 2008 financial crisis.
“And as we all know, it got out of control. And that's kind of how we got into the financial crisis of 2008.”
0:10:33 · Michael Hsu · Derivatives · 2008
A Super Bowl crypto advertisement featuring Larry David compared crypto to inventions like the wheel, the fork and the light bulb, which Michael Hsu says implies a false sense of inevitability.
“That Larry David ad is hilarious. It's a really funny ad. And it's very effective because it equates crypto to the wheel, the fork, the light bulb.”
0:12:15 · Michael Hsu · Crypto advertising · 2022
Michael Hsu says crypto is not always cheaper than traditional finance, citing very high gas fees on Ethereum.
“In some cases, it's not. I mean, look at the gas fees on Ethereum. Those are very, very high.”
0:14:23 · Michael Hsu · Ethereum fees · 2022
Michael Hsu cited statistics that almost one in five Americans owned crypto, about as many as have fixed income exposure.
“almost one in five Americans has crypto. Almost as many people have crypto as they do fixed income exposure.”
0:17:36 · Michael Hsu · Crypto ownership · 2022
The Financial Literacy Education Commission, co-headed by the Treasury and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, discussed crypto literacy at an event Michael Hsu attended.
“I was at a recent event with the Financial Literacy Education Commission, which is kind of co-headed by Treasury and the CFPB, and we were talking about crypto literacy.”
0:18:08 · Michael Hsu · Financial literacy · 2022
Michael Hsu said the total crypto market was worth roughly a trillion dollars or more and rested on about $180 billion of stablecoins.
“the crypto total value out there is around $2 1 trillion, plus or minus. That rests on about $180 billion of stablecoins.”
0:22:40 · Michael Hsu · Stablecoin market · 2022
Michael Hsu says the US dollar itself cannot exist on a blockchain, so dollar-backed stablecoins are how the dollar gets onto blockchains.
“The dollar cannot live on-chain. Stablecoins can live on-chain. The dollar cannot.”
0:24:11 · Michael Hsu · Dollar on-chain · 2022
Michael Hsu says money market funds needed bailouts in 2008 and again during the COVID-19 pandemic, which he uses to argue against a disclosure-only model for stablecoins.
“if you look at money funds, we've had to bail them out twice now. So in 2008, they had to get bailed out. And again, in the pandemic, they had to get bailed out.”
0:27:00 · Michael Hsu · Money market funds · 2008 and 2020
Michael Hsu says the President's Working Group on Financial Markets report recommended a bank-style approach for stablecoin issuers that want stability.
“that's why the PWG report has come out to say, hey, if you want this thing to be stable, you should take a bank approach.”
0:27:24 · Michael Hsu · Stablecoin regulation · 2021
Michael Hsu says that before the OCC existed, the US had an unstable free banking system with no uniform dollar, where each bank issued its own notes.
“Before the OCC existed, we had this really unstable free banking system in the U.S. where there was no uniform dollar.”
0:35:03 · Michael Hsu · Free banking · Before 1863
Michael Hsu says the National Currency Act and the creation of the OCC began to stabilize US money and produced an interoperable dollar across the country.
“And with the National Currency Act and the creation of the OCC, you start to stabilize it. You have an interoperable dollar across the whole country.”
0:35:34 · Michael Hsu · National Currency Act · 1860s
Michael Hsu says major stablecoins such as Tether and Circle's USD Coin are not interoperable and must be traded to move from one to the other.
“The stablecoin world we have today does not have that, right? A USD, a Tether, USD, C-Circle, those are not interoperable.”
0:38:15 · Michael Hsu · Stablecoin interoperability · 2022
Michael Hsu says hacks such as the Axie, Polygon and Wormhole incidents were caused by weaknesses in cross-chain bridges.
“Those are fragile. These hacks, the Axie hack that just happened, Polygon, Wormhole, are because of these cross-chain bridges.”
0:39:27 · Michael Hsu · Bridge hacks · 2022
Michael Hsu notes that TCP/IP was a deliberately created standard on which the rest of the internet was built, and he draws a lesson for crypto standard-setting.
“TCP IP was created, right? It was a standard that was created upon which everything else kind of gets built on top of it.”
0:40:42 · Michael Hsu · Internet protocols
Michael Hsu says some of the public-minded technologists who helped set internet standards at bodies such as the W3C and the IETF are now part of the crypto world.
“some of them are actually today part of the crypto world, are saying, hey, they were part of W3C and IETF and these kinds of things.”
0:41:24 · Michael Hsu · Standards bodies
Vitalik Buterin's blockchain trilemma holds that a blockchain can achieve only two of three goals: decentralization, security and scalability.
“Vitalik Buterin has highlighted this blockchain trilemma. You can have decentralization, security, scalability. You can basically have two out of three, but you can't get all three.”
0:44:34 · Michael Hsu · Blockchain trilemma
Michael Hsu says Ethereum has struggled with scalability while keeping decentralization and security, whereas alternatives like Solana give up decentralization to scale.
“some of the alternatives to Ethereum, like Solana, basically give up decentralization for scalability.”
0:45:07 · Michael Hsu · Ethereum and Solana · 2022
Michael Hsu cites a blog post by Moxie Marlinspike arguing that centralized intermediaries will always exist, so full decentralization at scale is unrealistic.
“And I think Moxie Marlins Spike kind of highlighted this in one of his blog posts, you know, was skeptical of saying, hey, there's always going to be centralized intermediaries.”
0:45:07 · Michael Hsu · Decentralization critique · 2022
Michael Hsu says a decentralized autonomous organization is essentially just a set of rules, which makes it hard for regulators to identify who or what to hold accountable.
“A DAO is just a set of rules. And so like, what do you grab?”
0:49:54 · Michael Hsu · DAOs
Michael Hsu says a Cornell researcher has described maximal extractable value (MEV), a form of front-running on blockchains such as Ethereum, for which regulators lack good tools.
“Philip Dan at Cornell has talked about minor extractable value. You got this MEV problem with Ethereum or with some of the blockchains in general, which is basically front running.”
0:50:27 · Michael Hsu · MEV