OpenNashPodcasts

Fintech One-On-One

Michele Alt, Co-Founder of Klaros Group, on the new era for fintechs and bank charters

15 May 2025 · 35m · Michele Alt, Peter Renton · 24 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Michele Alt, a former OCC official and co-founder of Klaros Group, argues that fintechs now face a far friendlier bank-chartering climate. The Biden years approved no fintech-oriented applications, while the new administration's regulators say they are open for business. She stresses that buying a bank and applying for a new one are equally hard to get approved. They differ mainly in when the work falls.

The central tension is between the opportunity and its limits. Pent-up demand could swamp regulator staff, and the Federal Reserve may not turn as fast as the bank agencies. Special charters such as industrial loan companies, state limited-purpose charters and crypto-focused charters each offer a narrower path. Big tech's interest in an industrial bank could trigger a political fight like the one that stopped Walmart in 2006.

Key insights

  1. Buying a bank isn't easier to approve

    Alt says regulators examine an acquisition as hard as a new-bank application. The difference is timing: a new bank puts more work after approval, and an acquisition puts more work before it.

  2. Existing banks bring both help and baggage

    Alt says an acquired bank comes with management, operations and systems, which is both its benefit and its drawback. That marriage can be painful if the fintech and the bank do not fit.

  3. Industrial loan companies avoid Federal Reserve oversight of parents

    An ILC is a full bank, but its parent company is not regulated as a bank holding company by the Fed. That makes it attractive to fintechs and to non-financial firms such as carmakers.

  4. Limited-purpose charters hinge on master accounts

    State charters like Georgia's or Wyoming's give narrow banking powers, but are only useful if the holder can reach payment systems. Custodia's fight with the Fed chilled interest, and Alt reads Stripe's application as confidence that access will come.

  5. A big tech bank would spark political war

    Alt notes Walmart withdrew its 2006 industrial bank application under pressure from the banking industry. She expects an Amazon or Google attempt to draw a similar fight, now with powerful players on both sides.

Questions

Is it easier for a fintech to buy a bank than to start a new one?

No. Michele Alt says regulators judge both routes equally strictly. An acquisition needs more work up front to find a target, while a new bank needs more work after approval to build it.

What is an industrial loan company (ILC) and why do companies want one?

An ILC is a full bank that can offer a wide range of services, but its parent is not supervised by the Federal Reserve as a bank holding company. Alt says that makes it the only route for firms like carmakers and a prized option for fintechs.

Why was Stripe's Georgia charter application a big deal?

Georgia's merchant acquirer limited purpose bank charter had sat unused for over 10 years. Alt says applications by Stripe and another big player suggest they are confident of getting a Fed master account or card network membership.

What is a Fed master account and why does it matter?

Alt describes it as something fintechs often need, along with card network membership, without wanting the rest of a traditional bank. Without one, narrow state charters lose their point, as Custodia Bank found in its fight with the Fed.

Could Amazon or Google get a bank charter?

Alt says they could only do so through an ILC, which frightens incumbent banks. She expects an all-out political fight like the one that ended Walmart's 2006 attempt, but she would still advise trying.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Michele Alt says no fintech-oriented bank application was approved during the Biden administration.

“During the Biden administration, not a single fintech-oriented application was approved.”

0:02:59 · Michele Alt · Bank charters · 2021-2025

Figure's bank applications were begun in Trump's first term and ran into regulatory headwinds when the Biden administration took over, according to Michele Alt.

“Well, those applications, which were begun in the Trump's first Trump 1.0, really ran into some serious regulatory headwinds when the Biden administration took over.”

0:03:51 · Michele Alt · Figure applications · 2021

Peter Renton says Varo Money obtained a de novo bank charter at great expense and has not been followed by other fintechs.

“The other path, obviously, is a de novo bank charter, which Varo Money famously did and and spent a fortune and have not actually been followed up with others.”

0:04:35 · Peter Renton · De novo charters

SmartBiz acquired Centrust Bank to form SmartBiz Bank.

“And they went down the acquisition route, acquired Centrust Bank to form SmartBiz Bank.”

0:07:51 · Peter Renton · Bank acquisition · 2025

Michele Alt believes SmartBiz began exploring its acquisition about three years before and filed its application more than a year before approval.

“I think that the idea and the exploration of the acquisition began three years ago. The actual application was filed more than a year before it was approved.”

0:10:35 · Michele Alt · Approval timeline · 2025

Michele Alt says the Biden-era regulators' groundwork let the OCC under its acting comptroller quickly approve SmartBiz's acquisition.

“their groundwork laid the path for the OCC under the acting comptroller's leadership to quickly approve.”

0:09:36 · Michele Alt · Regulatory approval · 2025

OakNorth, a UK small business lender, acquired Community Unity Bank in a recent US deal.

“But they acquired Community Unity Bank, an interesting name.”

0:11:49 · Peter Renton · Bank acquisition · 2025

OneMain, a long-time consumer lender, recently applied for an industrial loan company charter.

“But anyway, they have recently applied for an ILC charter.”

0:12:39 · Peter Renton · ILC application · 2025

Industrial loan companies have existed for more than 100 years, typically letting non-bank businesses offer banking services to their customers and employees.

“ILC stands for Industrial Loan Company. They have been around for more than 100 years, typically to allow non-bank concerns to provide banking services for their customers and employees.”

0:13:19 · Michele Alt · Industrial loan companies

Michele Alt says there are only 26 industrial loan companies in the United States.

“But an ILC is an exceedingly rare bird. There are only 26 in the United States.”

0:14:17 · Michele Alt · Industrial loan companies · 2025

General Motors and Stellantis have industrial loan company applications pending, according to Michele Alt.

“So, when you think industrial, think of the applications pending right now from General Motors and Stellantis.”

0:14:17 · Michele Alt · ILC applications · 2025

Only six states offer ILC charters, and Utah is the predominant provider, according to Michele Alt.

“there are only six states that offer ILC charters to start with. Utah is the predominant provider of ILCs.”

0:15:48 · Michele Alt · ILC states · 2025

Stripe applied for Georgia's Merchant Acquirer Limited Purpose Bank charter.

“I had never heard of the Merchant Acquirer Limited Purpose Bank Charter, M-A -L-P -B, that Stripe applied for with Georgia.”

0:17:43 · Peter Renton · State charters · 2025

Georgia's merchant acquirer limited purpose bank charter has existed for more than 10 years but saw no use until recently, according to Michele Alt.

“The Georgia Maltby has been on the books for more than 10 years. And until recently, no use cases have resulted from that legislation.”

0:18:16 · Michele Alt · State charters

Wyoming created the Special Purpose Depository Institution charter, aimed mainly at crypto companies, some years ago.

“SPEEDE stands for Special Purpose Depository Institution. And Wyoming created the SPEEDE charter, gosh, maybe not 10 years ago, but it's getting to be a while.”

0:21:17 · Michele Alt · Crypto charters

Caitlin Long of Custodia Bank was heavily involved in drafting Wyoming's special purpose depository institution legislation.

“Caitlin Long from Custodia Bank was very involved in the drafting of that legislation.”

0:21:17 · Michele Alt · Crypto charters

Custodia Bank has been in a dispute with the Federal Reserve over access to a master account.

“has been in a battle with the Fed over master account access for her bank, for Custodio Bank.”

0:21:58 · Michele Alt · Master accounts

Michele Alt believes Finality has applied for a Connecticut uninsured bank charter, amid new filings for state limited-purpose charters.

“something seems to be brewing that's gotten filings for the Georgia Mulby and the Connecticut Uninsured Bank, which I believe Finality has applied for.”

0:21:58 · Michele Alt · State charters · 2025

The Wall Street Journal reported that Circle and BitGo were applying for bank charters.

“Circle and BitGo, Wall Street Journal reported this, are supposedly applying for a bank charter.”

0:25:38 · Peter Renton · Crypto charters · 2025

Jonathan Gould was nominated as Comptroller of the Currency and had his Senate confirmation hearing about a week before the recording.

“Jonathan Gould has been nominated and had his Senate confirmation hearing a week ago, nominated to be the comptroller of the currency.”

0:26:16 · Michele Alt · OCC leadership · 2025

Jonathan Gould was chief counsel under Brian Brooks, a crypto-friendly regulator, during Trump's first term.

“he was the chief counsel under Brian Brooks during Trump 1.0, a very crypto-friendly regulator.”

0:26:16 · Michele Alt · OCC leadership · 2017-2021

Michele Alt says Federal Reserve Governor Michelle Bowman, a former community banker, strongly supports new bank formation.

“Governor Mickey Bowman is very keen on encouraging new bank formation. She has a background as a community banker.”

0:24:36 · Michele Alt · Federal Reserve · 2025

Walmart's 2006 application for an industrial loan company charter set off an intense backlash from the banking industry.

“ILCs were the sleepy little space until Walmart applied for an ILC in 2006 and set off an absolute firestorm.”

0:29:11 · Michele Alt · Walmart ILC · 2006

Walmart withdrew its industrial loan company application after an industry campaign against it.

“there was an all out push against Walmart to the point where Walmart was pressured to withdraw its application.”

0:29:58 · Michele Alt · Walmart ILC · 2006

Chapters

  1. 0:02:59A 180-degree turn in charter policy

    Alt contrasts the Biden years with today's regulators and sets the tone for the episode.

    “During the Biden administration, not a single fintech-oriented application was approved.”
  2. 0:06:04Acquisition versus de novo bank

    Alt dispels the idea that buying a bank is easier to approve and explains how the timing differs.

    “There is no difference in approvability.”
  3. 0:08:20SmartBiz, Centrust and OakNorth deals

    Recent acquisitions show how long approvals took and that regulators are now moving faster.

    “a board at the bank that was highly supportive of the change in control”
  4. 0:13:19What an industrial loan company is

    Alt explains why ILCs are rare, why parents avoid Fed oversight, and why Utah dominates.

    “An ILC is a real bank. It can engage in a full range of banking services.”
  5. 0:19:17State limited-purpose charters

    Georgia and Wyoming charters aim to fit narrow fintech models, but depend on payment-system access.

    “square peg round hole problem with the existing charters when it comes to fintech”
  6. 0:21:58Crypto, the Fed and federal regulators

    Crypto firms are targeting federal charters while the Fed's attitude on master accounts remains uncertain.

    “wound up locked in a battle with the Fed.”
  7. 0:26:16Crypto firms see a window

    Alt ties the crypto interest in federal charters to the nomination of a crypto-friendly Comptroller.

    “the crypto companies are seeing a window of opportunity”
  8. 0:29:11Big tech, Walmart and the ILC fight

    Walmart's failed 2006 bid shows why a big tech ILC would set off a political battle.

    “until Walmart applied for an ILC in 2006 and set off an absolute firestorm”
  9. 0:33:05Outlook for the next four years

    Alt predicts many more fintechs becoming or buying banks, with some scaling up.

    “I am confident that we'll see many more fintechs become banks”

Transcript

0:00:07
Michele Alt

There is no difference in approvability. That is the most important thing I want listeners to understand. The regulators will look just as hard at an acquisition as a de novo application, full stop. The timing is different. And here's how it differs. If you think about a de novo application at a very high level, you put together an application for a bank you would like to build. You submit that application. It is reviewed by the regulators, hopefully conditionally approved.

0:00:43

And then you build the bank. With an acquisition, the first step is finding and coming to terms with an acquisition target. Once you do that, you apply to acquire the bank, you submit the application, it is reviewed, and when it is approved, you have an operating bank. So think about the comparison is really with the de novo, there's probably more work at the back end. With an acquisition, there's more work at the front end.

0:01:18
Peter Renton

This is the FinTech One-on-One Podcast, the show for FinTech enthusiasts looking to better understand the leaders shaping FinTech and banking today. My name is Peter Renton, and since 2013, I've been conducting in-depth interviews with FinTech founders and banking executives. Today on the show, we are talking bank charters with one of FinTech's leading experts on the topic. I'm delighted to welcome back to the podcast, Michele Alt, the co-founder and managing director at the Klaros Group.

0:01:51

Michele spent more than 22 years working at the OCC, so she knows the bank chartering process intimately. And with a new administration, there is renewed interest in bank charters as the attitude in Washington has changed dramatically. If you have questions about bank charters, Michele has answers. Now let's get on with the show. Welcome back to the podcast, Michele. Thanks, Peter. I'm delighted to be here. All right. Well, it's great to have you. I just was looking.

0:02:29

It's been three and a half years since I last had you on the show. And I'll link to that in the show notes, the previous the previous interview we did, but I would say a lot has changed in those last three and a half years. And so maybe we can start off by talking about what has changed with the new administration and particularly when it comes to the different paths fintechs can take to get a bank charter.

0:02:59
Michele Alt

Well, what hasn't changed is a shorter subject than what has changed. I'm happy to say that when it comes to new bank formation and bank acquisitions, we are 180 degrees from where we were during the Biden administration. During the Biden administration, not a single fintech-oriented application was approved. Yeah, that's staggering when you think about four years. Four years. And those were long years. And Peter, I'm curious if you link to our earlier discussion, I may have been talking about my hopes for the figure and truth applications.

0:03:49
Peter Renton

You talked at length about figure, yeah.

0:03:51
Michele Alt

Yeah. Well, those applications, which were begun in the Trump's first Trump 1.0, really ran into some serious regulatory headwinds when the Biden administration took over. And what is abundantly clear in my recent visits to Washington and my many conversations with regulators is that the welcome mat has been rolled back out. And there's profound interest in new bank formation.

0:04:35
Peter Renton

Right. That is good news. So there's really, I guess, two main paths, right, for a fintech. And it seems to be one path has become more popular than the other. The first path is acquiring a bank, which several fintechs have done. And I know you've been involved in one. Some will get to that in a minute. The other path, obviously, is a de novo bank charter, which Varo Money famously did and and spent a fortune and have not actually been followed up with others.

0:05:10

But when you're looking at the two paths, is one better than the other?

0:05:17
Michele Alt

No, one is not better than the other. And I'm glad you asked me that. I spent a lot of time dispelling the assumption that an acquisition is somehow better, more easily approved, faster. Let me explain. They are different. It's the difference between getting a bespoke suit or buying off the rack and having it tailored. There's appropriate occasions for either suit. And so sometimes it's overkill to go bespoke. sometimes you would do better having something custom made to your measurements.

0:06:04

So what I mean by that is that the good thing about acquiring a bank, I often tell my clients, is that it comes with existing management operations and systems. And the bad thing about acquiring a bank is it comes with existing management operations and systems. And that marriage can be a painful one for some fintechs and some banks. There is no difference in approvability. That is the most important thing I want listeners to understand. The regulators will look just as hard at an acquisition as a de novo application, full stop.

0:06:49

The timing is different. And here's how it differs. If you think about a de novo application at a very high level, you put together an application for a bank you would like to build. You submit that application. It is reviewed by the regulators, hopefully conditionally approved. And then you build the bank. With an acquisition, the first step is finding and coming to terms with a target, an acquisition target. Once you do that, you apply to acquire the bank, you submit the application, it is reviewed, and when it is approved, you have an operating bank.

0:07:39

So think about the comparison is really with the de novo. there's probably more work at the back end. Within acquisition, there's more work at the front end.

0:07:51
Peter Renton

Okay. That's good to know. So let's talk about one deal I know you were involved with, because I saw it on LinkedIn, and that was SmartBiz. And they went down the acquisition route, acquired Centrust Bank to form SmartBiz Bank. Now, I've had Evan on the show, the CEO of SmartBiz a couple of times, but I'd love to get your perspective on what took place

0:08:20
Michele Alt

there and why they went down the route they did. Well, SmartBiz was very fortunate. It was very deliberate in its search for the ideal target for its business. And it found and sent trust that ideal target. It sent trust. There were many synergies in business focus, a focus on small business lending in particular. They had simpatico management teams, a board at the bank that was highly supportive of the change in control and the benefits to the bank, its shareholders and its customers of being acquired by SmartBiz.

0:09:08

So that was a very happy marriage, I would say.

0:09:14
Peter Renton

That must have started, because it happened fairly recently. We're only, as we're recording this, we're just over three months into the Trump administration. So I imagine this must have begun under the Biden administration. Did the timing, did you delay the timing on trying to make that happen deliberately?

0:09:36
Michele Alt

No, we did not delay the timing. We worked according to SmartBiz and Centrust timing. And credit where credit is due, you were correct that most of the work was conducted during the Biden administration and the regulators are to be commended that they gave SmartBiz a thorough, objective look. I think that they would have been approved by the Biden administration agency's leadership eventually, but their groundwork laid the path for the OCC under the acting comptroller's leadership to quickly approve.

0:10:21

Smart Biz.

0:10:23
Peter Renton

So what was the timeline there? Like when did they, well, from the time they decided they wanted to acquire a bank to the time they got approved, what sort of timeline are we talking?

0:10:35
Michele Alt

I, you know, Evan Wood, Evan Singer, the CEO of Smart Biz, will I hope, correct me if I'm wrong. I think that the idea and the exploration of the acquisition began three years ago. The actual application was filed more than a year before it was approved.

0:10:59
Peter Renton

Okay. Do you expect that timeline to be similar going forward?

0:11:03
Michele Alt

I expect it to be shorter. I have spoken with the leaders and acting leaders of the banking agencies, and they are committed to processing applications. more efficiently than has been the case in the past.

0:11:23
Peter Renton

That is good news. So another one that was recently, another recent deal that got done is Oak North. Now, a lot of listeners might not know Oak North well because they've been, they're a UK company. I've known them for a long, long time because we've had the CEO speak at our London events in the past. I've interviewed Rishi, the CEO on my podcast. And they have made, they've made it very clear for a long time that the U.S.

0:11:49

was a major target for them. They're another small business lender doing larger loans than what Smart Biz does. But they acquired Community Unity Bank, an interesting name. Not easy to say fast. Not easy to say fast. So what can you tell us about that acquisition?

0:12:11
Michele Alt

Well, I think that that acquisition is just further proof that the regulators are open for business. Again, I don't think that the takeaway should be the way to go is acquisition. That is an analysis each applicant should do according to its own strategy and timing and the pool of potential acquisition targets available.

0:12:39
Peter Renton

them. Right, right. Okay. So I want to move on to a new application, not an acquisition. And it's not for, I don't know what you call it, a regular bank charter. It's for an ILC. And it's from OneMain. And OneMain, I don't think they're really a fintech. They've been a brick and mortar lender, short-term consumer lender for decades. I think it goes back many decades. But anyway, they have recently applied for an ILC charter. Maybe you can start by just reminding us what's the difference between the ILC charter and the regular bank charter?

0:13:19
Michele Alt

Yes. An ILC is a real bank. It can engage in a full range of banking services. but it is not a bank that subjects its parent under the Bank Holding Company Act to supervision by the Fed. And for that reason, it is the ideal charter for a company that is not limited in its activities to those that are permissible for a bank or financial in nature. So, ILC stands for Industrial Loan Company. They have been around for more than 100 years, typically to allow non-bank concerns to provide banking services for their customers and employees.

0:14:17

So, when you think industrial, think of the applications pending right now from General Motors and Stellantis. Right. Those companies cannot meet the definition and the requirements for a bank holding company because they make cars. Making cars is not part of the business of banking. So for some companies, an ILC is the only game in town. But an ILC is an exceedingly rare bird. There are only 26 in the United States. And they are kind of the holy grail.

0:14:54

They are desired by all sorts of fintechs because they would really prefer not to have their parent regulated as a bank holding company by the Federal Reserve.

0:15:05
Peter Renton

Even though, like, obviously, Stellantis, General Motors, they make cars. They got nothing necessarily to do directly with finance, although they have massive financing operations. Right. Whereas OneMain, their business is finance. They don't have, so one main could have gone down the regular bank charter route, but they decided not to. What do you think, is it just because of that, what you mentioned, the Federal Reserve oversight?

0:15:33
Michele Alt

That is my assumption. Right. I don't know that directly from that, but that's my assumption. That's the primary benefit to pursuing an ILC.

0:15:41
Peter Renton

And why are most ILCs, and I don't think, not all, but most are located in Utah?

0:15:48
Michele Alt

They are. And I think that's of historical artifact. Utah has the most, there are only six states that offer ILC charters to start with. Utah is the predominant provider of ILCs. And they have a little bit the benefit of not being the first in the space, the most dominant in the space. And as a result, the Utah DFI is very familiar with ILCs. And Utah itself has an unusual pool of talent that is ILC experienced. So it's sort of Utah's success breeds more success.

0:16:37

But one of the things when I talk to potential applicants, I encourage them to consider other states as well. One issue that I'm sure we'll get to in a moment more broadly is that with the pent-up demand for applications, we are going to see relative flood and relative compared to the absolute little drip, drip, drip over the last few years of applications. And the regulators will not necessarily have the staff available to handle all of them all at once.

0:17:21

And so one thing to consider is that Utah may have less capacity to review applications than another state. I'm not saying that they do. It's just a potential. So that's one reason to consider other states.

0:17:43
Peter Renton

Okay, interesting. So I want to talk about some of the other unusual bank charters. I mean, I'm sure you're all fully aware of this. I had never heard of the Merchant Acquirer Limited Purpose Bank Charter, M-A -L-P -B, that Stripe applied for with Georgia. And a lot of people made a big deal out of this. Oh my God, Stripe's become a bank. But from my reading of it, this is a, as the name says, limited purpose.

0:18:13

And tell us a little bit about what that charter really means.

0:18:16
Michele Alt

Yes, the MALPB, the MOPB, the MOPB, it's a real mouthful. It is indeed a limited purpose financial institution. A number of states have created alternative charters to those offered at the federal level or state for more traditional bank models. The Georgia Maltby has been on the books for more than 10 years. And until recently, no use cases have resulted from that legislation. But it's interesting. In the last year, Pfizer applied, Stripe applied some big players. And you can assume they wouldn't be pursuing a charter unless they thought it would be very useful to them.

0:19:17

To put this in context, the state alternative charters are really trying to solve what is a square peg round hole problem with the existing charters when it comes to fintech. A lot of fintechs have limited business models, you know, more on one side of the balance sheet than others and then the other side. And traditional big charter really may be overkill for their needs. What often fintechs need is they need a master account. They need membership in the card networks.

0:19:58

They don't necessarily need everything else that comes with a traditional bank. And that's where these states are trying to step in and fill that gap. Yeah. But no one was applying for the Georgia Maltby or some of the other alternative charters because of the uncertainty of getting accepted into the card networks or getting a Fed master account. So the thing to read when you're reading the tea leaves here is if Fiserv and Stripe have decided to pursue that, they are pretty confident about their ability to gain a master account and or card network membership.

0:20:41

So that is a big development.

0:20:44
Peter Renton

Right, right. But obviously, Stripe is not looking to take deposits, right? They're looking at this from, they're a payments business and they want to acquire merchants directly, I guess. Right. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Okay. So another interesting, I think you even called this yesterday, Speedy. Speedy. S-P -D-I. And I don't actually remember what that stands for, but Wyoming has the Speedy Charter. and there's been some crypto firms that have received that charter. Maybe tell us a little bit about what that does.

0:21:17
Michele Alt

A SPEEDE stands for Special Purpose Depository Institution. And Wyoming created the SPEEDE charter, gosh, maybe not 10 years ago, but it's getting to be a while. And the idea really there is to provide a limited purpose bank charter for crypto companies, for the most part. It can be used for other purposes, but this was definitely, they had in mind crypto. Caitlin Long from Custodia Bank was very involved in the drafting of that legislation. She's a brilliant woman.

0:21:58

Very interesting to talk to on this subject and wound up locked in a battle with the Fed. has been in a battle with the Fed over master account access for her bank, for Custodio Bank. And that particular problem has, for the most part, I would say chilled interest in these alternative charters, because what's the point if you can't get a master account, if that's what you're seeking? So that uncertainty has put a question mark around All of the state limited purpose banks, although with the noted caveat that something seems to be brewing that's gotten filings for the Georgia Mulby and the Connecticut Uninsured Bank, which I believe Finality has applied for.

0:22:55

So there's developments there. I think if Congress takes up the call for a payments charter to create a payments charter, that we'll see a lot of activity there rather than through these state alternative charters. And the regulators are now, again, a 180 degree turn from crypto choke point to crypto receptivity. So I think we're going to see a lot of action on the crypto side at the federal agencies.

0:23:30
Peter Renton

But Custodia Bank still doesn't have their Fedmaster account, right? Is that litigation ongoing?

0:23:38
Michele Alt

I believe, Peter, I haven't checked the status lately. but yeah that's that's been a that's been a saga right well yeah so imagine if if the federal

0:23:52
Peter Renton

reserve ends up changing their mind and mind you the federal reserve is not a political organization where the um you know we we know that there's not going to be a new head of the fed until next year as a recording this trump had just said that he's not going to fire um jay paul we'll see if he keeps his word. You just never know. But, you know, so it may not be that the Federal Reserve, and what you're reading on the Federal Reserve, as the bank regulators have moved 180 degrees, the Federal Reserve doesn't necessarily move with them.

0:24:30

So, do you think that there's going to be any pressure on them to change their tune with some of this?

0:24:36
Michele Alt

I think there is pressure on the Fed. I also think that Governor Mickey Bowman is very keen on encouraging new bank formation. She has a background as a community banker. She believes firmly in the importance of new and innovative bank formation. I think she will be advocating for lessening of restrictions that are impediments to new bank formation. I don't know if that includes some softening on the approach to the tiered approach to master accounts that the Fed takes.

0:25:20

I think you're right. The Fed is less political generally. and they are slow to turn, like turning around a freighter in the ocean. I will, but it is a space I'm watching with great interest.

0:25:38
Peter Renton

Right, right. And then before we go on, I want to talk about crypto because this was in the news this week that Circle and BitGo, Wall Street Journal reported this, are supposedly applying for a bank charter. The rumors are that Coinbase and Paxos are also looking at it. I mean, we are, this is a very crypto-friendly administration. What's sort of your expectation when it comes to those kinds of banks? Now, they're doing this, they're not going to the Wyoming charter, they're going to the federal charter.

0:26:15

What's your reading on that?

0:26:16
Michele Alt

Well, my reading is certainly that the crypto companies are seeing a window of opportunity. I think they're correct to perceive that that window is open at the federal level. Jonathan Gould has been nominated and had his Senate confirmation hearing a week ago, nominated to be the comptroller of the currency. As you'll probably recall, he was the chief counsel under Brian Brooks during Trump 1.0, a very crypto-friendly regulator. And I think that the crypto companies are very excited to come in and explore their options under Comptroller Gould.

0:27:01
Peter Renton

Yeah, and he may well be confirmed by the time this is published.

0:27:05
Michele Alt

That would be my expectation.

0:27:07
Peter Renton

Yes, yes. Okay, so then what about big tech? Because there's been, you know, we've had Google. Google did some things a few years ago. You know, Amazon has obviously the resources. I mean, they could apply for an ILC potentially. They're obviously not in the business of finance. But what's your, are we going to see bank charters with tech companies anytime soon, do you think?

0:27:35
Michele Alt

Well, get out the popcorn. Because we're going to talk about something pretty interesting here. So, let's talk about big tech. Let's talk about ILCs. Let's put it in context here for what we're really watching when we get the popcorn out. As I said, an ILC is a very rare bird. And the intention is to allow companies that are not limited to the business of banking to provide banking services to their customers and employees. So there are applicants that can only become a bank with an ILC charter.

0:28:16

And like General Motors, making cars is not in the business of banking. For example, Google is a tech company. It is not limited to the business of banking. Amazon sells stuff, right? It is not a bank. So if they wanted to enter banking, it would have to be within the current licensing scheme. It would have to be through an ILC. That scares the bejesus out of the incumbent banks. It is one thing for, say, a small industrial company with a limited product set and a limited footprint to operate a bank.

0:29:11

That's not going to create a competitive disadvantage for Chase or any of the big banks, let alone the community banks. So ILCs were the sleepy little space until Walmart applied for an ILC in 2006 and set off an absolute firestorm. Because what is more convenient than Walmart? They're everywhere. They have an absolutely loyal customer base that exists throughout the country. They visit the stores weekly, if not more often. They know how to deliver a standardized experience that their customers like.

0:29:58

That was very frightening to the industry, to the banking industry. And there was an all out push against Walmart to the point where Walmart was pressured to withdraw its application. And there the story sort of ended. You know, no one else tried it. if Google or one of these big companies made the attempt, we can expect an all-out political war. And it'd be really interesting to watch because Google and big tech are very powerful. They had a big influence.

0:30:40

Big tech had a big influence in terms of campaign contributions to Trump. we saw the big tech leaders sitting on the dais at the inauguration.

0:30:53
Peter Renton

In the front row, I think.

0:30:55
Michele Alt

In the front row. I am very interested to see how those political battles result. You have big players on both sides lining up. So if that happens, grab the popcorn.

0:31:09
Peter Renton

Yeah, it's going to be super, super interesting. And so if you were to advise, say Amazon came to Klaros Group and said, we want to hire you because we're exploring an ILC, what would you advise them right off the bat? Say, is this worth it or this is worth pursuing or is it really too difficult?

0:31:33
Michele Alt

Peter, what I think I'd first say if Amazon came calling would be, where's that package? um right but after that i would not i would say let's try it and here's why i would say let's try it i don't believe that our regulatory system should serve only the interests of the incumbents I think it should serve the interests of the people. Call me an idealist. But if someone can come along and provide services, financial services that people want in a convenient, accessible, and inexpensive and compliant way, they should by all means be allowed to do so through existing statutory limits.

0:32:32

So I would say as long as there is such a creature as an ILC, then let's try it, but be prepared for a fight.

0:32:45
Peter Renton

Right, right. Okay, so then in closing, let's fast forward to almost four years at the end of the Trump administration. What do you think the fintech landscape is going to look like, particularly when it pertains to bank charters in that time?

0:33:05
Michele Alt

I am confident that we'll see many more fintechs become banks, become or acquire banks. I think we will see some really beginning to scale. Typically, these are not big. When it comes to banking, big is a whole different beast, right? It takes a while to build a many multi-billion dollar bank. I think we will see some bigger fintechs starting to scale their banking business. And I think we will see a number of smaller fintechs having entered the business and operating smaller banks and getting the hang of being regulated as banks.

0:33:53

It'll be an interesting time.

0:33:55
Peter Renton

Right. Well, we'll have to leave it there, Michele. It's always great to chat with you. I always learn a lot when we chat, and I did today.

0:34:02
Michele Alt

And look, color coordinated.

0:34:04
Peter Renton

Yes, we are. Okay. Well, thanks again for coming on this show, Michele. Appreciate it.

0:34:10
Michele Alt

Anytime. Thank you so much, Peter.

0:34:12
Peter Renton

Okay. See ya. Bye. Okay. So I don't like to get political on my show, but when you are talking bank regulation, politics can have a real impact. The reality is that there has never been a better time for fintech companies to obtain a bank charter. And as Michele said, we are going to see many new fintech banks in the next four years. Even if we move back to an administration run by Democrats in four years, the fintech landscape will have been irreversibly changed.

0:34:46

And I think that's a good thing. Anyway, that's it for today's show. If you enjoy these episodes, please go ahead and subscribe, tell a friend, or leave a review. And thanks so much for listening.