OpenNashPodcasts

Barefoot Innovation Podcast

The Human Side of Technology -- Sopnendu Mohanty, Chief Fintech Officer of the Monetary Authority of Singapore

28 Dec 2018 · 46m · Sopnendu Mohanty, Jo Ann Barefoot · 25 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Sopnendu Mohanty argues that financial technology and regulation should be built around people, not around technology for its own sake. He says the real aim is to cut the trust deficit in finance, since regulation exists to cover trust gaps. If regulators put empathy into policy, he says, they will find a way to modernize.

The conversation moves from the Monetary Authority of Singapore's festival and its tools (a sandbox, Project Ubin, the MyInfo national ID data service) to the harder problems of financial inclusion and cybersecurity. The tension is that regulators are built to be slow and careful, while attackers are small, agile and determined. Mohanty says collaboration and empathy are the answer.

Key insights

  1. Regulation costs shrink as trust grows

    Mohanty says the cost of being regulated mirrors the trust deficit in a system. If technology raises trust, regulatory burden should fall.

  2. MyInfo removed Singapore's KYC trust gap

    Singapore collected trusted resident data into the national MyInfo infrastructure. With consent, banks can open accounts instantly with no paper, and no policy had to change.

  3. Empathy must extend to bankers and regulators

    Mohanty says empathy is not only for end consumers. It also covers bankers, compliance officers, risk officers and system designers, because they deliver the value to consumers.

  4. Cyber defense needs shared data and talent

    Mohanty names three levers: simpler ways to change user behavior, collaboration on talent, and sharing cyber intelligence. He calls governments' inability to share cyber data the elephant in the room.

  5. Singapore's size and diversity drive collaboration

    Mohanty says being a small island forces Singapore to collaborate. It also welcomes talent from anywhere, which gives it diverse partners who bring in their own networks.

Questions

What is the Monetary Authority of Singapore's fintech festival?

It is a large annual event run by Singapore's central bank, which the hosts say drew about 45,000 people in 2018. Mohanty says it began as a platform to bring the whole ecosystem together for open dialogue and to bring good ideas closer to the financial sector.

How does Singapore open bank accounts without paperwork?

Singapore built a national infrastructure called MyInfo that holds trusted data on residents. With a person's consent, banks pull the data online and open an account instantly, with no paper and no separate verification.

What does Mohanty mean by the 'trust deficit'?

He means the lack of trust in a financial system, which is why regulators have to check behavior. He argues that when technology builds trust, the regulatory burden goes down.

Why did Mohanty say the United States has an advantage?

Jo Ann Barefoot said the US is harder to fix because it has many regulators and thousands of banks. Mohanty replied that the US has the talent to lead regulatory modernization.

What advice does Mohanty give regulators who need to speed up?

He says to build empathy into policy, meaning to ask whether a policy is purposeful for the people it serves. He also says to experiment through tools such as sandboxes, pilots and cross-border projects, because the data they produce helps shape better policy.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Jo Ann Barefoot said the Monetary Authority of Singapore's fintech festival drew about 45,000 attendees in 2018.

“I think it has to be the world's largest financial conference. This year they had an incredible 45 ,000 people attending from all over the world.”

0:00:39 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Fintech festival · 2018

Jo Ann Barefoot said the festival is sponsored by a central bank, which she said is unique in the world.

“And it's sponsored by, think about this, a central bank. There's nothing else like that in the world.”

0:01:15 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Festival sponsorship · 2018

The Monetary Authority of Singapore launched Project Ubin to explore blockchain and distributed ledger technology for clearing and settling payments and securities.

“They launched Project Ubin, which explores use of blockchains and distributed ledger technology, or DLT, for clearing and settling payments and securities.”

0:02:03 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Project Ubin

Individuals in Singapore can open bank accounts instantly with full verification through a national infrastructure called MyInfo.

“individuals who can now easily and instantly open bank accounts in Singapore with full verification through a national infrastructure called MyInfo”

0:02:44 · Jo Ann Barefoot · MyInfo

The Monetary Authority of Singapore acknowledged that its government-database approach to know-your-customer checks was harder to apply to corporations than to individuals.

“The KYC effort turned out to be harder for corporations, which is something that MAS has been quick to acknowledge”

0:02:44 · Jo Ann Barefoot · KYC

Jo Ann Barefoot said that at the 2018 festival one of the large hanging signs read 'regulators', marking an area for regulators from around the world.

“the conference suspended huge signs from the ceilings that you could easily see from far away. And I was shocked by the fact that this year, one of those signs read regulators.”

0:03:38 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Regulator area · 2018

The earlier episode with Sopnendu Mohanty was recorded at an international regulators conference in Jakarta sponsored by the Omidyar Network and the Gates Foundation.

“And we recorded it at an international regulators conference that was sponsored in Jakarta by the Omidyar Network and the Gates Foundation.”

0:04:16 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Earlier podcast

Sopnendu Mohanty said the festival began as a platform to bring people from the whole financial ecosystem together for open dialogue, not as a conference.

“It was a platform where we can bring in people from the whole ecosystem to have an open dialogue.”

0:09:24 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Festival origins

Sopnendu Mohanty said the festival's keynote speaker this year was a blind programmer.

“it was the blind programmer he was the keynote speaker for the largest conference today”

0:10:41 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Festival keynote · 2018

Piyush Gupta, CEO of DBS, was scheduled to speak in the festival's closing session about life outside banking.

“Fyush Gupta, who is CEO of DBS, he will talk anything, anything, anything outside banking, how he thinks about the whole society.”

0:11:35 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Closing session · 2018

Sopnendu Mohanty said a 19-year-old Afghan immigrant to America would speak at the closing session about an AI engine for detecting breast cancer that he is deploying in Afghanistan.

“We have this 19-year-old Afghan immigrant to America. His name is Abu Qadr. He will talk about AI.”

0:11:35 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Closing session · 2018

Sopnendu Mohanty argued that the cost of being regulated is matched by the trust deficit in a system, so more trust lowers the regulatory burden.

“the cost of being regulated is almost a reverse of almost is a line in accounting the matching other side is the trust deficit”

0:18:20 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Trust and regulation

Sopnendu Mohanty said a company in Singapore's sandbox is using distributed ledger technology to settle insurance claims instantly for gestational diabetes detected in pregnancy.

“we have a company which is using BLT Met Life Women Labs which is solving settlement for just a small diabetes”

0:22:11 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Sandbox example

Sopnendu Mohanty said Ravi Menon gave a festival speech centered on why MAS acts, not on what it regulates.

“He gave the speech yesterday. It's all about why we are doing it. It's not about what we want to regulate.”

0:23:29 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Ravi Menon speech · 2018

Sopnendu Mohanty said the Singapore government technology agency and MAS built the MyInfo national infrastructure holding trusted data on all residents.

“The Guftech and MAS worked together, put a national infrastructure called MyInfo. We collected trusted data of all the residents.”

0:26:50 · Sopnendu Mohanty · MyInfo

Sopnendu Mohanty said Singapore banks offer onboarding through MyInfo, and no policy change was needed to remove the trust gap.

“You click any banking website it says on board through my info we did not change any policy here”

0:26:50 · Sopnendu Mohanty · MyInfo

Sopnendu Mohanty said Project Ubin brings regulators to distributed ledger technology to explore use cases and the policy impact of industry use.

“Project Ubin is about bringing regulators to a technology called DLT and explore use cases using this technology”

0:29:31 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Project Ubin

Sopnendu Mohanty said eight regulators had booths at the festival, styled like startup booths.

“you see today that eight regulators have a booth.”

0:29:01 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Regulator booths · 2018

Sopnendu Mohanty attributed Singapore's collaborative approach to its small size as an island nation.

“being a small country, we survive on collaboration. It's part of our DNA.”

0:31:46 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Singapore collaboration

Sopnendu Mohanty said Singapore values talent regardless of national origin, and that this diversity helps it collaborate.

“The only thing we respect is what you bring in. And the talent is respected here, irrespective of which country you come from.”

0:32:25 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Singapore talent

Sopnendu Mohanty said governments' inability to share cyber data is the elephant in the room for tackling cyber threats.

“The last, I think people, the elephant in the room is actually the inability of the government to share cyber data.”

0:35:30 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Cybersecurity

Sopnendu Mohanty said nobody attacks M-Pesa and that he raised this with an Indian governor, but he did not give an explanation.

“Nobody attacks M-Pesa. Yeah, that's true. That's true. No one attacks M-Pesa.”

0:36:12 · Sopnendu Mohanty · M-Pesa security · 2018

Sopnendu Mohanty said cyber attackers are small, agile and determined, and that this is why he believes there is less time than we think.

“they are small, agile. They have the best brain. they're determined to attack, they want to prove a point”

0:37:28 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Cyber threats

Sopnendu Mohanty said the best innovation will come from people working under the most constraints.

“The best innovation will come people with the most constraint.”

0:41:19 · Sopnendu Mohanty · Innovation

Jo Ann Barefoot said her first speaking event of 2019 would be at the FINRA RegTech Conference in New York in January.

“My first speaking event of 2019 is going to be in January in New York at the FINRA RegTech Conference.”

0:43:09 · Jo Ann Barefoot · Upcoming events · 2019

Chapters

  1. 0:00:39Introducing the festival and the episode's theme

    The host sets out why Singapore's central bank is a global innovation leader and why this talk centers on the human side of technology.

    “it's a FinTech festival. That is, it's a festival and it's a tech conference.”
  2. 0:10:41Why the festival shifted to the human side

    Mohanty describes how the festival began and how this year's programming moved from fintech versus banks to who the technology serves.

    “This is the first time we started pivoting to something interesting. Who we are doing this technology for?”
  3. 0:18:20Financial inclusion and the trust deficit

    Mohanty links inclusion to trust, arguing that regulatory burden falls as trust rises, and points to distributed technology as one path.

    “if you trust more the system the regulatory burden goes down”
  4. 0:26:50Empathy in policy and the MyInfo example

    Mohanty explains how empathy shapes Singapore's approach and how national ID data solved account opening without changing policy.

    “We did not change any policy here we just got technology to remove the last the trust gap”
  5. 0:31:46The regulator's toolkit and why Singapore collaborates

    The conversation covers sandboxes, pilots, Project Ubin and regulator booths, then why Singapore collaborates so well.

    “being a small country, we survive on collaboration. It's part of our DNA.”
  6. 0:35:30Cybersecurity and the M-Pesa puzzle

    Mohanty lays out three levers against cyber threats and raises the question of why nobody attacks M-Pesa.

    “The last, I think people, the elephant in the room is actually the inability of the government to share cyber data.”
  7. 0:39:10Advice for regulators: build in empathy

    Asked for first steps, Mohanty says empathy should reach everyone who delivers value, and that the best innovation comes from constraint.

    “If the regulators start building empathy to their thinking, we will find a way out.”

Transcript

0:00:00
Sopnendu Mohanty

Sounds like a moral science class. But it's not a moral science class. It is real. If the regulators start building empathy to their thinking, we will find a way out.

0:00:39
Jo Ann Barefoot

Barefoot Innovation starts right now. This is our second show with Sopnendu Mohanty, the Chief FinTech Officer of the Monetary Authority of Singapore. We recorded it this year at the MAS Annual FinTech Festival in Singapore, which is a truly remarkable event. Everyone should try to go to it if you possibly can. I think it has to be the world's largest financial conference. This year they had an incredible 45 ,000 people attending from all over the world. But maybe even more surprisingly, it's a FinTech festival.

0:01:15

That is, it's a festival and it's a tech conference. And it's sponsored by, think about this, a central bank. There's nothing else like that in the world. That fact captures the essence of the extraordinary global role that MAS is playing with its visionary managing director, Ravi Menon, and with Sopnendu Mohanty leading the fintech work. They are trying to create a new model of financial regulation. They have staked out a unique position in the world as leaders in fintech and regtech innovation, not only making Singapore a magnet for innovators throughout Asia and the world, but also leading on pretty much every modernizing idea that regulators themselves can undertake.

0:02:03

If you think about the kinds of innovation initiatives that regulatory bodies have been inventing around the world, MAS may be the one agency that's doing nearly all of them. They have a sandbox. They have a Singapore tech stack to ease software development and security and interoperability. They have a very robust set of multinational and bilateral agreements, including some that enable passporting of fintech licenses between countries. They launched Project Ubin, which explores use of blockchains and distributed ledger technology, or DLT, for clearing and settling payments and securities.

0:02:44

They have experimented with reforming the anti-money laundering know-your-customer process by building a government utility-style database as an alternative to making every bank conduct an individual KYC process. This turned out to work well for individuals who can now easily and instantly open bank accounts in Singapore with full verification through a national infrastructure called MyInfo because the government has collected data for all residents and enables banks to share and verify that online. The KYC effort turned out to be harder for corporations, which is something that MAS has been quick to acknowledge, and I think the acknowledgement itself is yet another model for how modern regulators should lead today, being proactive and trying things out, but with the realization

0:03:38

that some things aren't going to work and that therefore experimentation and testing are critical. Take a moment to picture this enormous conference with its massive cavernous exhibit hall, huge high-tech display booths from all the world's leading financial and technology companies, and picture the throngs of people, the 45 ,000 people trying to navigate it. To make that process easier, the conference suspended huge signs from the ceilings that you could easily see from far away. And I was shocked by the fact that this year, one of those signs read regulators.

0:04:16

And below it were innovative regulators from all over the world. I often think about and often quote, in fact, something that Soap the News said to me in our earlier podcast. That episode is called We Have Less Time Than We Think. I will link to it in the show notes. And we recorded it at an international regulators conference that was sponsored in Jakarta by the Omidyar Network and the Gates Foundation. As we talked that day, I was expressing admiration for the many initiatives that MAS was undertaking, but I observed, as Americans often do on this topic, that Singapore has an easier challenge than we do because they basically have one regulator and just a handful of banks, and we have

0:05:02

dozens of regulatory bodies and thousands of banks. So, Soap listened to that observation, and then he said to me something that I've thought back on a thousand times. He said, yes, but the U.S. has the talent. He said that we in the U.S. should be able to lead the world in regulatory modernization, given the abundance of world-class talent we have in our tech and financial and regulatory sectors. I think he is right about that, and I'm very excited to say that as we reach the end of 2018, I think the U.S.

0:05:37

regulators are clearly moving into innovation, proactive leadership modes. We're going to have a lot more on those exciting developments in upcoming podcasts. Soap, of course, was the busiest person at the MAS Festival, which, given its size, that is saying something. To record this talk, we ducked into a private VIP lounge away from the hubbub, except that I could see people lining up outside the lounge hoping to get his attention. Recording as we did in that moment on the festival's last day, I think our talk captures the excitement in his voice about the progress that MAS is making and also his insight that as their work in regulatory innovation is maturing, they're realizing something they didn't see at the beginning.

0:06:28

and that is that the key to this whole thing is the human side of technology. Not technology for tech's sake or for the financial industry's sake, but for the sake of solving people's real problems. In our conversation, he talks about the need to fix the trust deficit in finance and technology and to make new technology really truly work for people and not harm them. I first met on a panel I moderated at MIT's FinTech Conference when I was at Harvard a few years back.

0:07:04

These days, I see him every few months in some setting around the world. This fall, I saw him at Money 2020 in October and then at the MAS Festival in November and then a meeting in Seattle in early December. Remember, every time I encounter him, I can see that he is pulling even further away from the pack from all the rest of us in his thinking on regulatory innovation. He explains in the podcast that the secret to this is not necessarily that he's a great visionary, although I think he is, but rather that he is always listening to and learning from people throughout the whole financial ecosystem all over the world.

0:07:47

So that makes us all incredibly fortunate to be able to listen to and learn from him. This is going to be one of my favorite shows we've ever done because my guest today is Sopnendu Mohanty, the Chief FinTech Officer of the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Welcome.

0:08:13
Sopnendu Mohanty

Thank you. Thanks for having me.

0:08:14
Jo Ann Barefoot

We are at the MAS FinTech Festival and it is spectacular this year. As I understand it, you beat last year's record and have nearly 40 ,000 people here?

0:08:32
Sopnendu Mohanty

Yes, absolutely. It's still growing by the way you speak.

0:08:38
Jo Ann Barefoot

I know it's the largest fintech festival in the world. I think it's probably the largest financial conference in the world.

0:08:45
Sopnendu Mohanty

I don't know, one that's bigger. Somebody just told me, if you pick any financial topic, perhaps this is the largest one.

0:08:52
Jo Ann Barefoot

I think so. and I've been here the last two years. You've seen the growth. I have seen the growth. It's been absolutely incredible. It's such an exciting event, and I will say before we go further too, you and I did an earlier podcast show when we were in Jakarta, what, two years ago or so, which I will also link to in the show notes, but I guess I'll start by asking you to talk a little bit about the festival itself, and then we're going to talk about what's happening.

0:09:24
Sopnendu Mohanty

The history behind this festival was this idea that can we create a platform. It was never a conference to start with. It was a platform where we can bring in people from the whole ecosystem to have an open dialogue. And in my mind, three years back, it was a small few hundred people within MAS to do this together. But as we start discussing with the community, we put in the website, I don't know, something happened, just a momentum got created that we can do bigger.

0:09:58

Then we got kind sponsors to come in and they said, we love this idea, let's do it. But back in my mind, I was thinking that ultimately what we want to do, we want to bring the best idea closer to the financial sector. And we spoke last time, if one thing I'm very passionate about is get the talent charged stuff yes and to charge of the talent you need a platform where they can talk exchange get inspired uh and have have some way to exchange the opportunity they want to create so that was the genesis of doing that and luckily for us the community support has been fabulous the the platform is growing uh we'll grow further uh if that

0:10:41

that's that's the way and more importantly i think what happened this year in particular we have changed the tone. Earlier it was about I have a problem I got to solve. Banks don't like us, please like us. Banks and FinTech one of them will survive we don't know. This is the first time we started pivoting to something interesting. Who we are doing this technology for? It's a human side of technology. That is the reason when we started this year keynote it was the blind programmer he was the keynote speaker for the largest conference today we had a topic from from harvard uh innovation lab technology is dead and his theory was it is not for the human beings uh development

0:11:35

no point in using technology And tomorrow we are ending the whole show with what you call the premium or key closing session with three people talking together about life outside banking. Fyush Gupta, who is CEO of DBS, he will talk anything, anything, anything outside banking, how he thinks about the whole society. We have this 19-year-old Afghan immigrant to America. His name is Abu Qadr. He will talk about AI. His AI engine has developed to detect breast cancer, which he's deploying in his home country, in Afghanistan, for women.

0:12:17

And the third one is a lady who's a completely blind, PhD in AI, solving problem for the blind. So we have pivoted from financial payment lending to much more human side of the discussion this year. I think that is driving a huge momentum for us that it has to be inspirational, purposeful, and it should have people betterment, life improvement as core to the thing.

0:12:48
Jo Ann Barefoot

That is so, as you say, inspiring to hear and so in line with what I found myself thinking about lately that we've got, you know, you can't frame these issues as financial narrow topics, financial products or regulatory problems or whatever. Really technology is going to transform everything about how we live and how do we shape that as you say, we're people. And those of us who are talking about it on the financial channel need to talk more widely.

0:13:23
Sopnendu Mohanty

Yes, and absolutely, I agree too. And the whole issue around, it's a disgrace in my mind, in spite of remarkable technology, in spite of so much wealthy countries around us, we still have billions of people who don't have access to capital and who can't improve their life if they don't have access to capital. It's a problem to be solved for. I think we have waited so many years to fix it. If we can't fix now, we can't fix ever.

0:13:56

We have got the technology, we have the young talent, momentum is out there, they are hungry to solve the problem. Consumer has become digital. Human mind has moved to adopting digital in a natural way. The mobile phone has gone to the poorest of the poor. They have a device which is very powerful, and the computing power is more than the power which somebody told the rocket which went to NASA, NASA built to send to the moon.

0:14:25

If you put the solutions out there, design intuitively, put the human aspect behind it, I think we have a lifetime opportunity to fix this problem forever.

0:14:37
Jo Ann Barefoot

So I want to turn to that. But before we leave talking about the festival, I just want to say I wish people who aren't here could see this festival. Because, first of all, again, it's huge. I mean, the excitement, the feeling of just walking through the exhibit hall here is unbelievable. And the other thing that struck me this year is the stage, the main stage, is so, the production value. I mean, the fact that this is being put on by a central bank is just mind-boggling.

0:15:13
Sopnendu Mohanty

I mean, it's just incredible. I think this is what we took inspiration from America. And my brief to the team is that everything we do, we must think about people who have given their other things in their life and they're going to spend the next three days with us. Everything that touch and feel has to have value. They should feel good. Their experience should be something they could remember. We don't want them to regret they have left something more valuable to spend time with us.

0:15:45

So everything they do, the food they eat, the experience they have, the people they interact, the content they pick up, everything has to be valuable so that they can go back and where they come from and say, look, I spent three good days in Singapore of real value.

0:16:02
Jo Ann Barefoot

And you've broken it out of the, frankly, boring conference mode that so many of us spend time in. And that widens people's thinking, it gives them energy. So I just can't compliment it enough.

0:16:20
Sopnendu Mohanty

And more important, we're celebrating human achievement. Because if you see around, there are so many small parts of 100 people setting capacity. we have told anybody want to speak go there and speak I'm not going to bet you whether you're a great speaker or a great just be there and if you are successful I'm watching next year you are coming through stages so so so we are watching these people whom we didn't invite to speak and next year some of them I put them big stage I found remarkable people out there telling great stories so you

0:16:50
Jo Ann Barefoot

also discovering speakers Wow okay so we could spend the whole episode talking about the conference but i want to go back to what you said a minute ago so i've said this to you before you are you and i have known each other for a few years now and we see each other every few months yes and every time i see you you have exponentially grown your insight i i think highly of other regulators as well, but I think that you have really been uniquely visionary in what can be done to make finance better with regulatory enabling behind that.

0:17:37

So that said, let's go back to where you were a moment ago when you said, if we can't solve the problem of financial inclusion now, we never will. So how are we going to solve it?

0:17:49
Sopnendu Mohanty

I don't. I think my sense is that at the end of the day, we need great talent to solve it. I think people have to solve it. And I think the idea is to discover the right talent, be thoughtful about policies which will facilitate this transition. It's all about trust. Even one of the things, the very existence of a regulator in a system like this, because there's a trust deficit. And any system that's a trust deficit, and there is somebody checking your behavior as a natural barrier to grow.

0:18:20

So as we build technology, as we build decentralized trust, and I'll go to the most fascinating topic about DLT, as we build decentralized trust, the system will have enough opportunity to solve a wider need. And if you think about in a very abstract sense, the cost of being regulated is almost a reverse of almost is a line in accounting the matching other side is the trust deficit if you trust more the system the regulatory burden goes down now how do you fix it one way we'll be centralized trust systems can it is possible we don't we're experimenting on

0:19:04
Jo Ann Barefoot

that that's it so specifically on distributed

0:19:07
Sopnendu Mohanty

So yeah, exactly. Can I distribute payment systems? Can I distribute so that the cost of technology goes down? The payments goes down. Can I distribute exchanges so that the cost of settlement goes down? So as we build technology, can I bring AI which will bring more people into the financial period system? So as we create this set of tools, our ability to reach out will increase. I hope, I sincerely hope, policymakers will align themselves and start crafting policies which will reduce some of this barrier.

0:19:42

And in that process, we should be able to capture a wider set of population whom we have not captured in the part of our social upliftment. And I hope we can solve the problem. I think that really the responsibility of fixing lies with us in the financial sector, whether you are an academician or you are a banker, it's our job. And if you do a good job and your regulatory burden goes down, hopefully we'll get there.

0:20:11

But I'm quite optimistic and you have known me for many, many, now many months and years. I'm not a visionary, as you say, but I have a place with the ability to get into an ecosystem where every moment I meet people, they tell me new things and I improvise on that. So I'm a bit of an incremental refinement to what I get. So I'm not the original thinker. I just incrementally refine what comes to me.

0:20:38
Jo Ann Barefoot

Well, part of what you're saying is you're connecting up people who are doing amazing things and that definitely is the magic that we need. It's in the connections that everything accelerates.

0:20:50
Sopnendu Mohanty

It's impossible one person to solve the problem. We just have to bring all together. It's difficult. It's challenging, but that's the journey.

0:20:59
Jo Ann Barefoot

So we're going to drive down the cost through technology. We're going to deliver financial services to everyone through the mobile phone. We're going to build distributed trust. Go ahead.

0:21:12
Sopnendu Mohanty

I just want that. So you also have to, I'm going to repeat again, reduce the trust deficit. That's the key. Because more you reduce trust deficit, better or simpler becomes your governance. That's the key. Because regulation is all about covering that risk and the trust deficit you have in the system.

0:21:38
Jo Ann Barefoot

So what besides distributed ledgers can work on that problem?

0:21:43
Sopnendu Mohanty

I think that people, there are many things people are doing in the whole ledger space. You only come efficiency and then you have this altruistic view of how life should be. But I am quite limited in my thinking is that we are looking deeply into how this technology can solve the things we spoke about. It does not contribute to the things we care about. I don't think I'm going to indulge on things which doesn't matter to me.

0:22:11

example in Singapore sandbox today we have a company which is using BLT Met Life Women Labs which is solving settlement for just a small diabetes one out of three women in Singapore during pregnancy they detect just a small diabetes the process is moment the doctor detects an instant settlement happens you're covered to be able to these are the things I'm interested in not some Bitcoin transfers and get those are things which somebody has to figure it out my job is to focus on human problem so Singapore is one of the few

0:22:58
Jo Ann Barefoot

countries in the world that really is driving this kind of change and through the regulator. I mean all the regulators are engaged in this but Singapore really has been at the forefront of saying we have a vision for change and we're going to engage the ecosystem. So talk a little bit first about sort of what what you're doing. Give us the quick version of what the building blocks of that are and then I want to ask you sort of how you make it work so well.

0:23:29
Sopnendu Mohanty

I think we start with Ravi Menon as a boss. He gave the speech yesterday. It's all about why we are doing it. It's not about what we want to regulate. That's less about what you want to regulate. We don't take a remarkable pride that we regulate too many things. That's something we should not be so excited about. It's about how you're solving human problems. And he talked about the six-tack, identity, payment is to be invisible, insurance to be intuitive, and he talks about those four issues of solving the...

0:24:08

We'll link to the speech in the show notes. So he talks about that. And if you think about his speech, his speech is all about empathy, solving human problems. End of the day, as a regulator, whom you're protecting? You're protecting our citizens, their interests. And if that's our job, we should start thinking about where we're heading to. My sense is that from a Singapore voluntary authority perspective, our managing director has clearly laid out this purposeful finance as our collective thinking.

0:24:44

In our staff meetings, in our staff gathering, we talked about empathy. everything we do, our policy should have empathy built in. When I say empathy, it doesn't mean empathy to the people who are going to take benefit of the policy. People who are going to execute the policy also, we should be empathetic to them. And so how do you bring empathy to everything we do? I think that kind of solves it. It's very simple, but it solves the problem.

0:25:12

And if regulators start empathizing on the end outcome, I think they will have a better position to craft a more smarter policy. Wherever they think they cannot solve the problem, we should find a technology partner who can solve the problem. If that doesn't get solved, we remain with that residual risk and find a way to govern that. Can you give an example of where you find a technology partner to help solve the problem? Absolutely. I think we are...

0:25:41

There's an example I can give you. For example, last year, we wanted to solve, if you think about, maybe we'll craft a different bit. There are three barriers to bank account. Getting yourself onboarded. Once you're onboarded, whether you are bankable through credit access. And lastly, manage your wealth. The first biggest barrier for all the financial institutions is how to onboard cheaper, in an efficient way, in a trusted way. Right. To meet the know your customer. And the whole regulatory burden is severely skewed to the know your customer.

0:26:21

That's the biggest expense. Yep. So, and that was a block. And we have put all kinds of policies to ensure that KYC is actually done in a very, very strict, safe and secure way. Nothing wrong with that. We have to do it. We have to protect the system. Now, I can have as many empathy I want, but we know that's a risk. We cannot relax our policy. There comes the beauty of technology. What happened in Singapore?

0:26:50

The Guftech and MAS worked together, put a national infrastructure called MyInfo. We collected trusted data of all the residents. We told the banks, we have the trusted data of the individual. with the consent take the data online on board no paper no checking you're done today banks account get opened instantly singapore with no paper no verification straight through is that already reached yes everyone 20 all our institutions are using it you click any banking website it says on board through my info we did not change any policy here we just got technology to remove the last the trust gap the trust gap with the data trusted that's all about the regulation so once you what i think about impact to

0:27:34

policy we are now saying if you're using my info this doesn't count so the trust deficit got solved by a technology solution and the regulation just so so that's a remarkable example where policy and regulation gets efficient because we remove that trust definition. Using technology.

0:27:58
Jo Ann Barefoot

We did an episode with Sanjay Jain whom I know you know. And we'll link to that as well. But India did it in a different way. But they came up with a way to enable everyone to identify themselves.

0:28:13
Sopnendu Mohanty

Absolutely. In India case, they build it.

0:28:15
Jo Ann Barefoot

But I did that with him in Jakarta, Indonesia.

0:28:18
Sopnendu Mohanty

And the policy makers kind of react later on to make it work, and they had a constant issue they solved now. But again, I'll not go there, but I think it's all about how to craft a solution which reduces the trust deficit, and the way to do it is using technology. And to me, that's what I'm interested in.

0:28:38
Jo Ann Barefoot

Your other sort of elements of your innovation program that you lead, do you have a sandbox? What are the main elements? Because I know we have a lot of regulators listening who are thinking, what does a good program look like for the regulator to explore innovation and try to figure out how to?

0:29:01
Sopnendu Mohanty

I think there's no magic formula. We have five or six ways to solve it. One is, of course, the classic experimental thinking. sandbox, participate in proof of concept, engage in pilots. Fintech festival is a great tool for regulators to inspire. In fact, you see today that eight regulators have a booth. I did see that. Who's look like a startup booth. I saw them. We have a US regulator here as well. Exactly. So then that's another platform to engage.

0:29:31

Then we have cross-border project like Project Ubin. Regulators are participating, banks are participating. Same with that. Yeah. So, Project Ubin is about bringing regulators to a technology called DLT and explore use cases using this technology and think about what is the policy impact when industry uses technology. To me, these five, six things are the tools available for regulators to start improving their thinking. I always say, if you are informed, if you're educated, if you're experimental in thinking, the empirical data which comes out of it helps you to shape your policy better, more meaningful and much more safe.

0:30:16
Jo Ann Barefoot

So I was hanging around today at the regulator booth and chatting with one of them.

0:30:24
Sopnendu Mohanty

Sorry, can you imagine regulators booths on a, inside of FinTech conference? Everywhere in the world they talk about our regulator trusting FinTech. In a FinTech conference, the regulators are sitting and putting a booth. It's almost reversed. It's unbelievable.

0:30:39
Jo Ann Barefoot

There's a lot of countries here. A lot of them. From all over the world.

0:30:44
Sopnendu Mohanty

To me, if I have to pick 10 unique things in this conference, regulators are putting a booth. They would know how good they are inside a FinTech conference.

0:30:53
Jo Ann Barefoot

Absolutely. There's a whole section called, what is it called?

0:30:56
Sopnendu Mohanty

Regulator booth, a regulator's area or something like that.

0:30:59
Jo Ann Barefoot

It's got a cooler name. Yeah, yeah. I can't remember what it is. But there's a big sign up.

0:31:02
Sopnendu Mohanty

Think about it. Think the philosophy, the abstracted and the cultural shift has happened to the ecosystem. Regulators putting a booth inside a fintech conference.

0:31:15
Jo Ann Barefoot

You're right. That is just mind-blowing. So I was chatting with one of them and I mentioned I was going to do our podcast today. And I said, so what should I ask them? And so one of them said, ask him how, why Singapore is so good at collaborating. He said, Singapore is the best country in the world in partnering and collaborating with other regulators. And is, I mean, beyond what you've already said, what's the secret to that?

0:31:46
Sopnendu Mohanty

Oh, that's a hard question. I think one of the things is, being a small country, we survive on collaboration. It's part of our DNA. We're just a small country. And if we don't collaborate, how we'll succeed? So that's partly unfair on other countries. Good point. It's an island. Yeah, it's an island. And the natural force is to collaborate. So that's an advantage we have. The constraint makes us very collaborative. And the second thing, Singapore has always focused on good talent.

0:32:25

The only thing we respect is what you bring in. And the talent is respected here, irrespective of which country you come from. There's no such thing about where you come from, different cultural values. No problem. I think the diversity in our ecosystem, the diversity in our talent, really makes this country a remarkable place to do new things. We are kind of blessed because of so many global talents sitting here trying to help us to collaborate. When you say we collaborate, because we have people who are ready to collaborate.

0:33:02

And it comes from the same diverse thinking. If you have diverse people, they have matching diverse people on the other side. and they will bring in their friends and families to collaborate. So by the design, it is designed to collaborate. Almost Singapore is designed to collaborate.

0:33:19
Jo Ann Barefoot

So I know we're going to run short on time and I know you are the busiest person at this 40 ,000 person conference so I don't want to be greedy with your time but I want to ask you about two other things. One is I want you to talk. So you were at Money 2020 in Las Vegas with us. a couple weeks ago, and you said there something you also said on the first podcast, which is how much you worry about cybersecurity.

0:33:48

Talk a little bit about what that threat is and what we should be doing that maybe we're not doing.

0:33:54
Sopnendu Mohanty

There are a few things which we have started looking at is that part of the cyber defense is how do we equip people who are consuming these digital services to be almost like cyber literate. They should follow basic hygiene of interacting with cyber systems or cyber-based digital economy. And we are going to spend a lot of time and money to train people just to have good behavior, passwords protect very basic sounds so good but we know we're not gonna get everyone so we I think that's what I want to I want to challenge the status quo if you can if we can find a way to simplify or I think we over over design literacy people if we can

0:34:51

design a way we can make people aware of the cyber challenges and change the behavior I think half of the battle will be solved in that whole process. The second part of the battle is do we have tools and services which can counteract against this threat and if you can build a talent pool who are constantly looking at this risk and they can solve the problem, this is where collaboration is a big deal. If one thing we want to collaborate, like every country should collaborate is collaborate on cyber security.

0:35:30

And this whole collaboration can take away a big part of the remaining risk. The last, I think people, the elephant in the room is actually the inability of the government to share cyber data. If you don't share the data, if you don't understand all the data we get through this whole process, I think how do you solve the problem because you have not seen the problem. So sharing cyber intelligence through data sharing, creating collaboration on talent and educating the people about cyber challenges is perhaps in my mind the way to go and solve this problem.

0:36:12

And I was with the Indian governor today, I asked him, you must do something great. Nobody attacks M-Pesa. Yeah, that's true. That's true. No one attacks M-Pesa. So what is that you've done so good that they don't attack you? And why they attack other people? I don't want to disclose more on this thing, but I think that I'll leave it for next podcast. And because that's a fascinating topic to chase. Why nobody attacks M-Pesa?

0:36:43

Wow, that is thought provoking. Is it a certain behavior? Is it beyond cyber? Why a hacker doesn't attack MPSA?

0:36:55
Jo Ann Barefoot

So I didn't know that they don't get attacked.

0:36:59
Sopnendu Mohanty

You go and Google, tell me which MPSA got attacked.

0:37:02
Jo Ann Barefoot

So interesting.

0:37:04
Sopnendu Mohanty

Maybe the answer is there.

0:37:08
Jo Ann Barefoot

So you've got me thinking for sure. I think that when we did the earlier episode, I called it, I took a quote from you for the name of it, which was, you said, we have less time than we think. Yes. So you feel like we're in a race against time. The good guys against the bad guys. Yes.

0:37:28
Sopnendu Mohanty

Yes, absolutely. I think the reason we have less than because they are small, agile. They have the best brain. they're determined to attack, they want to prove a point, and that's their passion. And because they're passionate what they do, it's just a big challenge for all of us to go and counteract on this whole design to disrupt the system.

0:37:58
Jo Ann Barefoot

Okay, last question. So I've said this to you before, I'm going to say it again. And when we did the earlier show, I said to you that I admire what Singapore is doing, but I said, but Singapore has an easier challenge than the United States, because in the United States we have a whole lot of regulators, and we have thousands of banks, and we have a very complicated system, and so it's harder there to make the kind of progress that you're making.

0:38:27

And do you remember what you said to me? Yes, talent. Talent. You said the United States has the talent. and should be able to solve this. So what advice do you have for regulators that are listening, really for anyone, but especially for regulators that are, you know, know they need to speed up. They know they need to be able to process more data. They know they need to regulate more in real time. But they're built to be slow and careful.

0:39:01

I mean, it's not anybody's fault. that's the old system that we have. What are the first steps they should take, or the thing that they should grasp?

0:39:10
Sopnendu Mohanty

I would, and again, it's very difficult. If the regulators start putting empathy in their thinking, it sounds like a moral science class, but it's not a moral science class, it is real. If the regulators start building empathy to their thinking, we will find a way out. absolutely how did they go so you just you should carefully consider what is this policy has got the right element of empathy because end of the day you are doing you are regulating for somebody else somebody's benefit get the empathy part right make your thing make policy purposeful make policy for people I think we'll get it right.

0:40:03
Jo Ann Barefoot

So where did that come from here? I mean, every regulator cares about the public that they're protecting. But to put empathy at the center...

0:40:13
Sopnendu Mohanty

When people say public, empathy is not about the end consumer. It is the people who in between deliver that end consumer value. The bankers, the compliance officer, the risk officer, the system designer, Everybody comes. It's a construct which brings all together. So it's not a...

0:40:34
Jo Ann Barefoot

So it's a community, an empathetic community.

0:40:38
Sopnendu Mohanty

You cannot pick one and say, I'm empathizing on this set of people, so I don't care for rest. Because somebody has to do the rest to deliver that value. And did you all know this when you started Dennis Ruggs? No. No. You just do a research on Ravi Menem's slide, first festival. second festival and third festival. You are an academician, you are a researcher, do a psychographic analytics on this slide. The colors have changed. It has moved from a certain tone to a certain tone in three years.

0:41:17
Jo Ann Barefoot

And you learned it by doing it.

0:41:19
Sopnendu Mohanty

Discovery, collaboration, understanding the people around you. I want to end this podcast by saying the best innovation will come people with the most constraint. Go to this market where there are remarkable constraints and find out how technology can solve the problem and bring it back to

0:41:38
Jo Ann Barefoot

your country and make it better. That is a great note to end on. Let me ask you, where can people get more information about MAS and your innovation work?

0:41:48
Sopnendu Mohanty

All in our website. We publish everything in policy work, report, research, all that. And in In fact, we are upgrading our website. Hopefully that will create a very different, easy to navigate empathy, again, who want to come to our website is not great today, and fix it. We are looking to upgrade our website to get the whole knowledge, conferences, knowledge gathering, videos, policies, everything.

0:42:16
Jo Ann Barefoot

So we will link to that in the show notes. So Nandumahanti, I cannot thank you enough for joining us today. It's been fantastic.

0:42:24
Sopnendu Mohanty

Thank you. Thanks again for having me. We'll see you in Seattle shortly.

0:42:27
Jo Ann Barefoot

Oh, yes. You and I have a very interesting meeting coming up in Seattle. So that's going to be very exciting.

0:42:32
Sopnendu Mohanty

Thank you.

0:42:33
Jo Ann Barefoot

Thank you. Thanks for listening to our show with Sopnandu Mahanti, the Chief FinTech Officer of the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Again, come to jsbarefoot.com for much more information about him and the work of the MAS and its leader, Ravi Manon. We have great shows coming up. We're going to talk with Anju Padwarden of Credit Ease and Stanford University. We are going to talk with Walter Cruttenden, the co-founder of Acorns and co-founder and CEO of Blast.

0:43:09

We are going to have two shows from Boston, one on artificial intelligence with Steve Cohen of Basis Technologies and one with Lamont Young, who's leading digital innovation at Citizens Bank. And we're going to have an especially provocative and entertaining show that I recorded in London this fall in the Old City at Armorer's Hall with my friend Dave Birch. Next year's calendar is filling up. My first speaking event of 2019 is going to be in January in New York at the FINRA RegTech Conference.

0:43:44

I hope to see everyone there who's interested in fintech and the investment space. Watch for upcoming information on my collaboration with Brett King on his new book, Bank 4.0, which you can buy on Amazon. We have a link in the show notes. I co-wrote the regulatory chapter with Brett, and we'll have a show and events around that as well. If you enjoy listening to Barefoot Innovation, please be sure to post a review. That will help us get new listeners.

0:44:14

And please also follow along with me on Twitter at Joanne Barefoot and on LinkedIn and Facebook. Come to jsbarefoot.com for much more information. And come there to subscribe to the newsletter and get the latest podcasts as soon as they come out. And don't forget, please, to send in your dollar a show to keep all of it going. I want to wish you all the happiest of New Year's as we end 2018. It has been an incredible year, a turning point year in the U.S.

0:44:48

and globally in people embracing new kinds of tech innovation and using it to start to transform both finance and financial regulation into something genuinely better than we've ever known before. I have loved being with you all through these podcasts and in my travels around the world. And I'm grateful to you for all of your ideas, your insights, your knowledge, your energy, your support for what we're doing. And the building of a community, the building of a movement even, that is going to make all of this work better than it ever has before.

0:45:31

Happy holidays and Happy New Year.