OpenNashPodcasts

Planet Money

How Jane Street’s secret billion-dollar trade unraveled

24 Sep 2025 · 28m · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi, Mary Childs · 22 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Jane Street's Indian options trade shows how a secret edge can turn into a legal and regulatory problem once it is exposed. The firm says it was doing ordinary arbitrage, which means profiting from price gaps and helping prices correct. India's regulator, SEBI, says it was manipulating the market against millions of inexperienced day traders, most of whom lost money.

The central tension is that the same trades look like a service or like a rigged game, depending on who describes them. The firm's lawsuit over stolen trade secrets, meant to protect its strategy, instead exposed the strategy and drew regulators. Venki, one losing day trader, puts a human face on the other side of the trade.

Key insights

  1. A lawsuit meant to protect secrecy exposed the trade

    Jane Street sued former traders to guard a strategy, but courtroom remarks by the judge and a Millennium lawyer revealed the profit size and that it involved Indian options. That drew in competitors and regulators.

  2. India's options boom created the arbitrage opening

    The National Stock Exchange of India added more options in 2019, including daily expirations, and pandemic-era retail traders piled in. Their one-sided buying pushed option prices away from theoretical value, which gave Jane Street's algorithms gaps to trade against.

  3. Most retail options traders in India lose money

    SEBI found about 90 percent of retail options traders lost money, roughly 4 million people. Each lost nearly half the typical annual Indian income on average.

  4. SEBI says Jane Street's stock trades looked manipulative

    SEBI alleged Jane Street bought stocks in the morning to lift prices and enticed bets on a rise, then sold in the final hour to sink the index. Its options bet was seven times its stock purchases, which SEBI said pure arbitrage would not require.

  5. The fine is small next to the profits

    Jane Street posted half a billion dollars to an escrow account to lift its trading ban, but an analyst estimates it made over $4 billion in this market. The bigger cost may be lost secrecy and tighter Indian rules.

Questions

What is Jane Street and why was it so secretive?

Jane Street is a private trading firm that posted $20.5 billion in net trading revenue last year and now trades on the level of Goldman Sachs. The hosts say it keeps a low profile, gives few interviews and is intentionally a black box, so competitors can't copy its strategies.

What is arbitrage, in simple terms?

It means profiting from a price difference for the same thing, like buying oranges at $5 in New York and selling them at $10 in Chicago. In theory, the trading itself makes the gap disappear.

What did India's regulator accuse Jane Street of doing?

SEBI, India's version of the SEC, said Jane Street manipulated the market by buying stocks to lift prices, then selling them near the close to push an index down and win its options bets. SEBI says this made over $500 million illegally; Jane Street disputes it.

How does Jane Street defend its trading in India?

In a leaked memo, it said SEBI misunderstood index arbitrage and that its activity was unambiguously good for market health. It says its stock purchases were hedges and that its late selling was a routine way of exiting a position.

Who lost money on the other side of these trades?

Mostly everyday Indian day traders like Venki, who lost around $12,000 in a few days in January 2024 and now owes about $350,000. He says Jane Street definitely took some of that money, though he also blames himself and the regulators.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Jane Street Group reported $20.5 billion in net trading revenue in the year before the episode, about double the prior year.

“Last year, they posted $20.5 billion in net trading revenue, basically doubling from the year before.”

0:00:52 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Jane Street revenue

The hosts say Jane Street went from a little-known startup to trading on the level of Goldman Sachs in a couple of decades.

“in just a couple of decades, they've gone from being a little-known startup to trading on the level of Goldman Sachs.”

0:00:52 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Jane Street growth

Jane Street Group sued two former traders, alleging they stole a lucrative trading strategy and took it to competitor Millennium Management.

“Because now the company was accusing two of its former traders of stealing one of their most lucrative trading strategies and taking it to a direct competitor.”

0:01:38 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Trade secret lawsuit

Bloomberg reporter Chris Dolmetsch attended the hearing in the Jane Street lawsuit at a courthouse in lower Manhattan on April 19, 2024, per the episode.

“on the morning of April 19th, 2024, Chris buttoned up his shirt and went down to a courthouse in lower Manhattan.”

0:02:19 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Courtroom hearing · 2024

The judge in the Jane Street case revealed that the firm had made about $1 billion from the disputed strategy in 2023.

“the judge revealed what seemed to be an important detail, that Jane Street had made about $1 billion from this trading strategy in 2023.”

0:03:07 · Mary Childs · Strategy profits · 2023

In 2019 the National Stock Exchange of India began offering more kinds of options, eventually allowing daily and same-day-expiry options.

“In 2019, the National Stock Exchange of India, where a lot of this trading was happening, began offering more kinds of options for sale.”

0:11:15 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Options expansion · 2019

By 2023 India's options market had become one of the largest in the world.

“By 2023, India's options market had become one of the largest in the world.”

0:13:05 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Indian options market · 2023

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is India's equivalent of the US SEC and is tasked with protecting investors and ensuring fair markets.

“SEBI is basically the SEC of India. They are in part tasked with protecting Indian investors and ensuring fair play in their markets.”

0:18:39 · Mary Childs · Market regulator

A SEBI report found that about 90 percent of everyday retail investors lost money trading options, about 4 million people.

“SEBI completed a report, and what they found was that about 90 % of everyday retail investors were losing money on options trading.”

0:19:03 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Retail losses

According to the SEBI report, losing retail options traders lost on average nearly half the typical annual income in India.

“On average, they were each losing nearly half the typical annual income in India.”

0:19:03 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Retail losses

SEBI's most lucrative day for Jane Street was January 17, 2024, when the options trades focused on an index of India's largest bank stocks.

“Our Jane Street watcher, Rupak Hosh, pointed us to the most lucrative of those days, January 17th of 2024. He says on that day, the options trades in question were focused on an index of the country's largest bank stocks.”

0:22:15 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · SEBI case · 2024

According to SEBI, Jane Street bought between 15 and 25 percent of the traded value of the underlying stocks on the key trading day.

“according to Sebi, Jane Street ended up buying somewhere between 15 and 25 percent of the traded value of the underlying stocks.”

0:23:25 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Stock purchases · 2024

SEBI argues pure arbitrage would have meant stock purchases equal to the options bets, but Jane Street's options bet was seven times larger.

“Sebi argues that if Jane Street was simply doing arbitrage, their stock purchases should have been equal in size to their options bets. But here, Jane Street's options bet was seven times bigger.”

0:24:14 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · SEBI argument

SEBI alleges Jane Street sold its large stock holdings in the final hour of trading, pushing the index down and making its options bet pay off, a tactic called marking the close.

“Basically, in the final hour of the trading day, Jane Street began to sell their enormous stock holdings. That sell-off ended up sinking the price of the whole index.”

0:24:38 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Marking the close · 2024

SEBI says Jane Street netted around $83 million in a single day by misleading day traders.

“While Jane Street ultimately netted around $83 million in one day by intentionally misleading day traders, according to Sebi.”

0:25:02 · Mary Childs · SEBI allegation · 2024

SEBI says Jane Street used similar tactics for over two years and made over $500 million illegally.

“Sebi says Jane Street had used similar tactics for over two years, making over $500 million illegally.”

0:25:19 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · SEBI allegation

In a leaked memo to employees, Jane Street said SEBI misunderstood fundamental principles of index arbitrage.

“In a leaked memo, they told their own employees that SEBI was misunderstanding some of the fundamental principles of index arbitrage.”

0:26:01 · Mary Childs · Jane Street defense

Jane Street had its trading ban in India lifted by depositing about half a billion dollars into an escrow account.

“But Jane Street was able to get the trading ban lifted by forking over half $1 billion into an escrow account.”

0:26:51 · Mary Childs · Trading ban

Analyst Rupak Khosh estimates Jane Street made well over $4 billion in the Indian options market over a couple of years.

“Jane Street appears to have made well over $4 billion in this market over the past couple years.”

0:27:22 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Jane Street profits

Indian regulators cut the frequency of options expirations and raised the capital requirements for trading options.

“Indian regulators have cracked down on the frequency of options expirations, and they've raised the capital requirements for people to be allowed to trade options.”

0:27:41 · Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi · Regulatory crackdown

Jane Street Group and Millennium Management settled the trade secrets lawsuit for an undisclosed amount.

“Jane Street and Millennium ended up settling that lawsuit over stolen trade secrets last year for an undisclosed amount.”

0:28:50 · Mary Childs · Lawsuit settlement

Day trader Venkatesh Upadeya says his debts from options trading have grown to around $350,000.

“Vanky says his debts from day trading options have grown to around $350 ,000.”

0:29:20 · Mary Childs · Venki's debt

Chapters

  1. 0:02:38A courtroom hearing offers a rare window into Jane Street

    Jane Street sued former traders and Millennium over a trade secret, which gave a Bloomberg reporter a chance to see inside a very private firm.

    “It's like listening to elevator music and waiting for heavy metal to come in the middle.”
  2. 0:05:14The judge and a lawyer let slip the secret

    Remarks in court revealed the strategy was worth about $1 billion in 2023 and was tied to India, which turned a dull hearing into big news.

    “That's when he says there's a built-in system to trade in India, in some country, and then he apologizes.”
  3. 0:12:55Venki and the Indian options boom

    A day trader explains how new daily options and pandemic-era retail enthusiasm turned the Indian market into something like a casino.

    “So it was like a jackpot lottery daily.”
  4. 0:13:50How arbitrage gave Jane Street its opening

    Option prices drifted from their theoretical values because inexperienced traders crowded one side, and Jane Street's algorithms could trade against the gaps.

    “Arbitrage means taking advantage of a difference in prices for the exact same thing.”
  5. 0:19:03SEBI finds retail traders losing heavily

    The regulator's study shows how lopsided the market was and sets up the question of who was winning.

    “what they found was that about 90 % of everyday retail investors were losing money on options trading.”
  6. 0:24:14SEBI's manipulation case against Jane Street

    The regulator argues that big stock purchases and a late sell-off fixed the outcome of options bets on January 17, 2024.

    “But here, Jane Street's options bet was seven times bigger.”
  7. 0:26:01Jane Street's defense and the cost of the fight

    The firm calls its trades healthy arbitrage and hedging, while an analyst says the fine is small next to the profits.

    “unambiguously good for the health of financial markets.”
  8. 0:29:49Aftermath for the market and for Venki

    The gold rush is over for Jane Street, while Venki, deep in debt, says he can only trade his way out.

    “because trading is the only way that can bring me out of this debt.”

Transcript

0:00:00
Speaker 5

This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR. This is Planet Money from NPR.

0:00:19
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

On Wall Street, fortunes are often won and lost with the tiniest advantages. Like, can your firm find some brilliant trading strategy in some corner of the global market? Or can you keep it a secret from your competitors so they don't start cannibalizing your profits?

0:00:35
Mary Childs

And for the past few years, one trading firm has stood out from the rest for both huge profits and almost complete secrecy. A firm called Jane Street. Jane Street has become famous for making these incredibly high annual profits.

0:00:52
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Last year, they posted $20.5 billion in net trading revenue, basically doubling from the year before. And in just a couple of decades, they've gone from being a little-known startup to trading on the level of Goldman Sachs. But Jane Street is a private company. They don't give a lot of interviews or have any high-profile executives. They are intentionally a black box.

0:01:13
Mary Childs

So when Chris Dolmetsch, a legal reporter for Bloomberg News, first heard that Jane Street was bringing a lawsuit against one of its main competitors, he knew it was a big deal.

0:01:25
Speaker 3

Anything you write about Jane Street gets immediate huge attention. Nobody knew what this place was and what they did, really. They just made a lot of money and everybody wanted to know how.

0:01:38
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

And to Chris, this court case seemed like it might offer this incredibly rare window inside the black box of Jane Street. Because now the company was accusing two of its former traders of stealing one of their most lucrative trading strategies and taking it to a direct competitor. Jane Street alleged this competitor, Millennium Management, was now using that same strategy and eating into their profits.

0:02:02
Mary Childs

So Jane Street was asking the court to stop Millennium, to award Jane Street damages. And in order to prevent anyone else from figuring out their trade secrets about, you know, trading, they asked the judge to bar the public and reporters like Chris from the courtroom.

0:02:19
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

The judge declined that last request. And so on the morning of April 19th, 2024, Chris buttoned up his shirt and went down to a courthouse in lower Manhattan. He shuffled into the courtroom next to some of the most expensive lawyers money can rent. And he settled in for a marathon of dense legalese.

0:02:38
Speaker 3

These things are very dull, generally dull kind of hearings. Lots of lawyers talking, making very distinct points about the law. So you really have to pay attention. But you also are just kind of listening for anything that sounds, you know, interesting. It's like listening to elevator music and waiting for heavy metal to come in the middle.

0:02:58
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Heavy metal is the payday for you.

0:03:00
Speaker 3

Heavy metal moments where all of a sudden the guitars start playing and you're like, OK, that's a big deal.

0:03:07
Mary Childs

Chris says the trial began with a solid dose of elevator music. The first tiny hint of heavy metal came when the judge tried to find out how financially important this secret trading strategy was to Jane Street's business. In the course of asking that question, the judge revealed what seemed to be an important detail, that Jane Street had made about $1 billion from this trading strategy in 2023.

0:03:35
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Jane Street's lawyer did not comment on that number specifically, though she did say later that this strategy had recently been the most lucrative trade in their portfolio, all of which was like loud, distorted music to Chris's ears.

0:03:49
Speaker 3

When the judge says this is a billion dollar trading strategy, your ears perk up.

0:03:54
Mary Childs

Another hit of heavy metal came in an exchange about Jane Street's desire to keep the contours of their strategy as big as possible. Even down to where in the world this trade was happening. The judge expressed some skepticism.

0:04:09
Speaker 3

The judge said details of his trading strategy that might allow somebody to replicate it are one thing. The continent whose securities are at issue is quite another.

0:04:17
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Continent? As in like geographical continent? Geographical continent. Interesting.

0:04:25
Speaker 3

Like, that's the level of secrecy that they want here. You know, they don't even want to tell you this is on planet Earth. Anything like that would give anybody kind of a roadmap to find out what's going on, they don't want.

0:04:39
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Whether he meant to or not, the judge had sort of tipped people like Chris off that they were now playing a geographic game. Like, where in the literal world is Jane Street raking in all this money?

0:04:51
Mary Childs

Not too long after that, one of the lawyers for Millennium appears to offhandedly mention the kind of market that this trade was happening in, saying it was one of the largest options markets in the world. And in a final burst of screechy guitar, that same lawyer does something totally unexpected. He appears to maybe accidentally give up the exact location of the trade.

0:05:14
Speaker 4

That's when he says there's a built-in system to trade in India, in some country, and then he apologizes.

0:05:23
Speaker 3

and I knew the second he apologized that he had just revealed something that was going to be a big deal. That's more than a little bit of fake guitar music in the background. That's a big solo that I know is, oh, this is news. This is definitely news. We have a billion-dollar strategy. We know it's their most lucrative, and now we know where it is. Whatever it is, it involves options trading in India.

0:05:49
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Chris writes up his story, publishes it like he would any other story. But the information revealed in that courtroom would soon ricochet around the world. It would draw the attention of competitors and regulatory agencies, blow up billions of dollars worth of trades, and call into question some of the most fundamental strategies in global finance. Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi. And I'm Mary Childs.

0:06:16
Mary Childs

A few years ago, Jane Street discovered a sort of goldmine, a financial glitch in one of the biggest economies in the world that helped them become the envy of Wall Street. But when they tried to keep that goldmine a secret, things spiraled out of their control.

0:06:31
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Today on the show, what Jane Street's Indian options trade reveals about the power imbalance between Wall Street juggernauts and everyday traders, the surprisingly fine line between taking advantage of an opportunity and market manipulation, and the unintended consequences of trying to aggressively keep a trade secret.

0:07:00
Speaker 5

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR.

0:07:18
Speaker 4

This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently.

0:07:27
Speaker 3

But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planetmoneyshow. This message comes from Google Workspace with Gemini. One subscription that does it all. Personalized AI and premium business versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Drive, and more. Try it free for 14 days at goo.gle slash workspacewithgemini.

0:08:00
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

So a big part of the trading strategy that Jane Street was so desperate to keep secret seemed to center on three magic words. Indian options market. And in any market, on any given trade, there are two sides to the story. There is the buyer and there is the seller.

0:08:17
Mary Childs

In order to understand this market where Jane Street has been playing, we wanted to hear from someone on the other side of the trade. So we called up someone who spends a lot of his waking life Day trading. A guy named Venkatesh Upadeya, or Venki, as his friends call him.

0:08:34
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Do you have any hobbies? What do you do for fun?

0:08:36
Speaker 4

Fun? I used to watch YouTube videos, but no other hobbies. I spend the majority of my time in my home itself. So this trading is like a jail.

0:08:51
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Venki is in his early 50s. He says he first found out about trading after college. He was taking a course to be able to work in tax and legal compliance for corporations.

0:09:00
Speaker 4

But I tried for one year, but I couldn't complete because I was an average student. So I thought I would give it up.

0:09:10
Mary Childs

It was around that time that Venki discovered the hobby that would eventually come to feel like jail. In his free time, he would frequent old bookshops.

0:09:19
Speaker 4

And one day I came across a book named Business Today. And in that, there were figures like 5 ,000 crores, 6 ,000, 10 ,000 crores.

0:09:30
Mary Childs

Crore means 10 million. So Venki's reading about like 100 billion rupees, hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars.

0:09:38
Speaker 4

I thought, my God, in the world, such figures are there. And I came to know that through companies, people are making money.

0:09:47
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Venki started learning more about the stock market. He started making trades of his own. And a decade or so later, by 2008, he was trading full time. And eventually, Banky graduated from the stock market to the options market.

0:10:01
Mary Childs

An option is a way for investors to bet on a stock. It's a contract guaranteeing you the option to buy or sell a particular stock at an agreed-upon price on or before a specific expiration date in the future. So if you think Coke stock is going to rise, you can buy an option. And if it does rise, you can buy that stock at a discount and pocket the difference. If it doesn't, you can just let your option expire and eat the cost, whatever you spent to buy it.

0:10:30
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Banky says for a day trader like him, options were more appealing for a couple reasons. First, buying an option is generally much cheaper than buying the stock. And unlike in the U.S., the Indian stock market has way fewer buyers and sellers. So stocks are just harder to trade.

0:10:46
Speaker 4

The attraction of options is that we can do with very little amount of money.

0:10:50
Mary Childs

The second reason options were appealing is because they offer the prospect of high returns without needing a lot of money. If you happen to place a bad bet, you do stand to lose whatever you paid, but your losses are kind of limited. And if your bet pays off, you can potentially make many multiples of your investment.

0:11:09
Speaker 4

In some options, we can make 5x, 10x, even 50x we can make in some trades.

0:11:15
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

For a decade or so, Venki was in a relatively rarefied group. But then a couple things happened that caused the Indian options market to explode. In 2019, the National Stock Exchange of India, where a lot of this trading was happening, began offering more kinds of options for sale. Eventually, that meant Indian day traders could place bets on options every single day of the week, and even on options that expired the same day they bought them.

0:11:41
Mary Childs

And second was the pandemic. Remember how during the pandemic, an enormous horde of retail investors in the U.S. started banding together to pump up the value of meme stocks like GameStop and AMC? To the moon! Well, the same thing kind of happened in India for options.

0:11:57
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Yeah. While millions of lower and middle income people in India were stuck at home, they started taking to their cell phones and computers to get in on the rapidly expanding options market. All of a sudden, there was this whole ecosystem of slick financial influencers and options gurus touting their unbeatable investment strategies on YouTube and TikTok. Hello, traders. Today, we'll be discussing about an excellent and simple option trading strategy.

0:12:24
Speaker 4

Your risk is very less, but your profit is unlimited.

0:12:28
Speaker 5

In order to achieve financial freedom, many people are choosing for option trading. Learn tools and achieve the right mindset to face today's market confidently with me at How Pro Strade Options and Help Build Strategy from Zero.

0:12:43
Mary Childs

Over the past few years, millions of newly minted retail traders with a little money and zero experience flooded into India's booming options trading casino alongside Venki.

0:12:55
Speaker 4

So it was like a jackpot lottery daily. We had Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, all those, all days. So it became like a gambling spot.

0:13:05
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

By 2023, India's options market had become one of the largest in the world. And it was around that time that it became the focus of a secretive Wall Street trading firm called Jane Street.

0:13:17
Speaker 3

Global financial institutions are always looking for a new opportunity, a new asset class, a new geography.

0:13:23
Mary Childs

This is Rupak Khosh. He is a longtime corporate strategist and research analyst based in London. He's followed Jane Street pretty closely for years. And he says that by the time the options market started taking off, Jane Street had already been trading in India for a couple of years, developing fancy algorithms for identifying promising trades. And it was around the options boom that they seemed to notice what is known to investors and economists as an arbitrage opportunity.

0:13:50
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Arbitrage means taking advantage of a difference in prices for the exact same thing. So let's say you find out that oranges are selling in New York for $5 a piece. At the same time, they're selling for $10 in Chicago. You could spend 50 bucks on New York oranges, sell them in Chicago for $100, and pocket the difference. That is arbitrage. But the thing is, these opportunities don't usually last long.

0:14:15
Speaker 3

You bought the oranges in New York because they're cheap. You've sold the oranges in Chicago because they're expensive. You believe over time, as information flow between Chicago and New York is shared, the fundamentals are going to mean that those two prices close.

0:14:29
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

The key to arbitrage is recognizing a price differential and having the money and ability to trade on that information while the getting is good. Because eventually, in theory, the act of trading should cause the price difference to disappear.

0:14:43
Mary Childs

And when it came to the Indian options market, the price differential, the arbitrage opportunity that Jane Street noticed, had to do with the imbalance between the price of some options and the price of the underlying stocks they were betting on.

0:14:59
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

And this is kind of the key to Jane Street's strategy. You see, in theory, you should be able to calculate what the value of an option should be based on things like the price of the stock it's betting on, the stock's volatility and the amount of time before the option expires.

0:15:14
Mary Childs

But in the Indian options market, the option prices kept diverging from where they should be in theory. Because of all those masses of relatively inexperienced day traders placing bets based on, you know, whatever their favorite Finfluencer said. When they all bought or sold, swarming on one side or another, they often took the price with them.

0:15:36
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

That means sometimes people were paying more for some options than the options were theoretically worth. And using high-powered algorithms, Jane Street was able to identify these fleeting windows of opportunity. Arbitrage! Hey, that's an arbitrage!

0:15:51
Mary Childs

And if Jane Street saw an arbitrage opportunity, they could act because they had the money and the wherewithal to quickly set up shop on the other side of the trade. They could sell as many of those options at that inflated price as possible until demand came back down.

0:16:07
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Rupak says it was like Jane Street had discovered an open ocean filled with schools of tasty, defenseless fish.

0:16:15
Speaker 3

They entered, they saw the arbitrage opportunity, and they saw that the sharks were not there and the regulators were not there.

0:16:22
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Starting at least in 2023, Jane Street began running variations of this trade dozens of times, month after month, eventually racking up billions of dollars in profits, all without anyone outside the firm any the wiser.

0:16:35
Mary Childs

Until, of course, a couple of Jane Street traders decamped for a competitor. There was a lawsuit, and last April, on that fateful day in a Manhattan courtroom, Bloomberg reporter Chris Dolmetsch and the wider world first heard that it was Jane Street who'd been quietly winning all along.

0:16:51
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

But all of the profits Jane Street was raking in had to be coming from somewhere. After the break, Indian regulators tally up who had been on the other side of this clever, clever trading strategy. and just how badly they have been losing.

0:17:15
Speaker 4

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

0:17:19
Speaker 5

This message comes from University at Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first. Tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University at Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu slash NPR.

0:17:41
Speaker 4

This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently.

0:17:49
Speaker 3

But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planet money show.

0:18:04
Speaker 5

This message comes from Dell. Shop at Dell.com for Black Friday and find great PCs like the Dell XPS 13 laptop with a long battery life and powerful performance with Intel Core processors. Upgrade your whole setup for less. Dell.com slash deals.

0:18:21
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

When news broke in April of last year about how Jane Street had minted at least $1 billion from the Indian options market, the reaction was mixed. Other Wall Street firms were intrigued, but regulators with the Securities and Exchange Board of India, or SEBI, they were less than thrilled.

0:18:39
Mary Childs

SEBI is basically the SEC of India. They are in part tasked with protecting Indian investors and ensuring fair play in their markets. And they'd been concerned about the volatility and rapid growth in the Indian options market for a couple of years. They knew that having millions of inexperienced day traders gambling with their life savings was a potentially dangerous situation.

0:19:03
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

So a few years ago, this regulatory agency, SEBI, decided to dig into how these lower and middle income Indian day traders were actually fairing. You know, people like Venki. SEBI completed a report, and what they found was that about 90 % of everyday retail investors were losing money on options trading. Nine out of 10 people, which meant about 4 million people had lost money. On average, they were each losing nearly half the typical annual income in India.

0:19:31
Mary Childs

Now, it was clear to Sebi and others that a lot of that money was going to sophisticated, well-funded trading institutions lurking under the surface. But it wasn't until those unexpected courtroom revelations last April that it became clear that Jane Street was the primary winner here. Jane Street seemed to have been one of the main players helping people like Vanki place their questionable bets in the giant casino of the options market.

0:20:00
Speaker 4

It became like a daily jackpot lottery. The problem is that when we make quick money, we get carried away. So we don't see there is an equal chance of losing it.

0:20:11
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

When you describe the kind of mindset that's gotten you into trouble, I mean, is it like a sort of gambling mindset?

0:20:17
Speaker 4

Yeah, that's right. That's right. But this gambler's mindset was inside me. So that's a bad habit, I know.

0:20:27
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Vicky says for a time he was winning. At one point, he did manage to make around 25 times his investment in a month. But he says he quickly lost all of it and even started going into debt.

0:20:39
Speaker 4

Once the small debt started, to make up that loss, I again traded. Then it became a vicious cycle. I took much bigger risk, much riskier trades, and it started ballooning.

0:20:55
Mary Childs

Over the course of a few days in January 2024, Venki had his worst loss ever. He lost around $12 ,000 in just a couple trades.

0:21:06
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Do you think that some of the money that you lost went to Jane Street? Definitely. There's no question at all. They are the people who made money out of us. In fact, during one of those days in January, Jane Street was allegedly making millions upon millions of dollars from traders like Venki. It was those kinds of winnings that led Sebi to open an investigation into Jane Street's trading. And that investigation painted a very different picture of what Jane Street was up to in the Indian options market.

0:21:33
Mary Childs

There are basically two ways of looking at what Jane Street was doing in India. From the Jane Street perspective, what they were doing in India was just classic arbitrage. They were just using fancy algorithms to identify momentary price differentials in the options market, and meeting market demand, enabling traders to buy or sell whatever options they wanted until eventually the prices came closer into line with their theoretical value. And in economics, arbitrage is good for the efficiency of the market, because it helps to reveal what prices should really be.

0:22:06

Jane Street was providing a service. And yes, Jane Street got to make money from this, but it also meant that fewer people were now over or under paying for options.

0:22:15
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

But the Sebi view was that Jane Street was manipulating the market. Now, we reached out to Sebi. They declined to be interviewed. But they did release a detailed complaint they brought against Jane Street. Sebi zeroed in on a few particularly profitable trading days for Jane Street. Our Jane Street watcher, Rupak Hosh, pointed us to the most lucrative of those days, January 17th of 2024. He says on that day, the options trades in question were focused on an index of the country's largest bank stocks.

0:22:45
Speaker 3

So what happened is the options price for the index, the bank's index, was over 1 % above the cash price. So there was an arbitrage.

0:22:54
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

That morning, the market seemed to be clamoring for options, specifically betting that the stocks were going to go up in value by the time the options expired at the end of the day. That frothy demand was driving the price some 1.5 % above where they theoretically should be relative to the stocks they were tied to.

0:23:12
Mary Childs

So Jane Street started selling everyday day traders like Venki the options they were demanding. And at the same time, Jane Street started buying up bets that the stocks would go down at the end of the day.

0:23:25
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Also, as part of their arbitrage play that morning, Jane Street appears to have started buying the underlying stocks. This is the stock whose price at the end of the day would determine which bets won and which ones lost. And remember, the stock market in India doesn't have as many traders, so big purchases can make prices go up a lot. And according to Sebi, Jane Street ended up buying somewhere between 15 and 25 percent of the traded value of the underlying stocks.

0:23:54
Mary Childs

Sebi argued that Indian day traders saw the underlying stock prices hold or even grow in value, and they started pouring more and more of their money into bets that it would go up by expiration. And the regulator said that enticed traders into making the wrong bets. That was one part of how Sebi thought Jane Street manipulated the market.

0:24:14
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Sebi argues that if Jane Street was simply doing arbitrage, their stock purchases should have been equal in size to their options bets. But here, Jane Street's options bet was seven times bigger.

0:24:27
Mary Childs

Jane Street's second big manipulative tactic, Sebi alleged, was doing something known in the financial world as marking the close. This is the thing that Sebi seemed really mad about.

0:24:38
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Basically, in the final hour of the trading day, Jane Street began to sell their enormous stock holdings. That sell-off ended up sinking the price of the whole index. And since Jane Street had made an options bet that the index price would fall by the end of the day, their options bet paid off big time. Sebi says Jane Street had essentially fixed the outcome and created the future they bet would happen.

0:25:02
Mary Childs

And all the people on the other side of the trade, like Venki, who'd bet that the number would go up, they lost the money they'd spent on the options. While Jane Street ultimately netted around $83 million in one day by intentionally misleading day traders, according to Sebi.

0:25:19
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Sebi says Jane Street had used similar tactics for over two years, making over $500 million illegally. This past July, Sebi filed an interim order, a sort of temporary court order against Jane Street, and announced they would be banned from trading on Indian markets. Rupak Khosh, our Jane Street watcher, says Sebi kind of had to do something, because to him, it looked like Sebi and India's National Stock Exchange were playing catch-up.

0:25:47
Speaker 3

Well, the Indian regulator was sleeping at the wheel. This is about the foreign radar against the little guy. Because billions of dollars has left the Indian retail investor's pocket and has arrived in Manhattan.

0:26:01
Mary Childs

We reached out to Jane Street. They said they dispute SEBI's claims and will engage with the regulator. In a leaked memo, they told their own employees that SEBI was misunderstanding some of the fundamental principles of index arbitrage. They also said that the trading activity was, quote, unambiguously good for the health of financial markets. In the absence of participants like Jane Street, there would be no economic link between the Indian derivatives market and the underlying economy. Close quote.

0:26:29

As for their massive stock purchases, that could be explained as a way to hedge their bet.

0:26:34
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

As for their stock sell-off right in the final hour of the trading day that pushed down the price, Jane Street actually started selling their stock 30 minutes before the window usually considered marking the close. So that sell-off could be seen as a routine way of exiting a position at the end of the day.

0:26:51
Mary Childs

Jane Street announced they would be defending themselves vigorously in the Indian courts, and they have since filed an appeal against SEBI. They say an earlier investigation by SEBI's surveillance unit had already looked into this and didn't find any proof of manipulation. Whether all this will count as regular arbitrage or market manipulation will be up to the Indian legal system to decide. But Jane Street was able to get the trading ban lifted by forking over half $1 billion into an escrow account.

0:27:22
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

But Rupak Hosh says that even if Jane Street does ultimately lose the legal fight and forfeit the fines they've handed over, the firm is still financially way ahead. Jane Street appears to have made well over $4 billion in this market over the past couple years.

0:27:37
Speaker 3

My personal view is the $500 million is chump change. It's irrelevant.

0:27:41
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

But there is another kind of potential cost for Jane Street. The options market gold rush in India is sort of over. Jane Street no longer appears to be trading options in India like they were. Indian regulators have cracked down on the frequency of options expirations, and they've raised the capital requirements for people to be allowed to trade options.

0:28:01
Mary Childs

And maybe more importantly, the revelation of Jane Street's India trade and the regulatory backlash have put them on everyone's radar. For example, we are talking about them right now. Hi, Jane Street.

0:28:15
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

So what do you make of the decision then on Jane Street's part to sue their former traders in this way that ultimately exposed this trade?

0:28:25
Speaker 3

In England, we have a saying, penny wise, pound foolish. And that was penny wise, pound foolish. This is not some proprietary algorithm. This is not Mike, whatever, Nash sitting in Princeton in the beautiful mind, mathematical formulas on the wall, Russell Crowe, Nobel. This is just plain old school hustling, bullying markets. For that, this is going to go on for years.

0:28:50
Mary Childs

By the way, Jane Street and Millennium ended up settling that lawsuit over stolen trade secrets last year for an undisclosed amount.

0:28:59
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

As for day trader Venkatesh Upadeya, he has faith that India's regulators will hold Jane Street accountable for what he sees as an unfair and manipulative strategy. But he also blames those same regulators for letting the market get so out of control. And he blames himself for making risky bets over and over again.

0:29:20
Mary Childs

Vanky says his debts from day trading options have grown to around $350 ,000. His wife and children are worried and disappointed in him. Still, Vanky insists that the only way out of this precarious situation is through the market that brought him there.

0:29:38
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

So will you continue to trade in the Indian options market?

0:29:42
Speaker 4

Definitely, definitely. There is no option but to only trade in options.

0:29:47
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

No option but the options market.

0:29:49
Speaker 4

Yeah, because trading is the only way that can bring me out of this debt.

0:29:55
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

Venki knows he will always be swimming with far bigger financial fish, with faster and more sophisticated strategies and massive piles of money to take advantage of every opportunity they find. But he is hoping that if he's disciplined enough, maybe next time he won't come out on the bottom. If you want to hear more episodes about the wacky world of finance, we have one about a group of math nerds who thought they found a way to take risk out of investing, and another about how George Soros broke the British pound about three decades ago.

0:30:35

You can find those episodes and links to some source material for this episode in our show notes.

0:30:41
Mary Childs

This episode was produced by Eric Mennel with production help from Sam Yellowhorse Kesler and Cooper Katz-McKim. It was edited by Jess Jiang and engineered by Jimmy Keely. Fact-checking by Sierra Juarez. Our executive producer is Alex Goldmark.

0:30:52
Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi

We had invaluable reporting help from Omkar Kandekar. And special thanks to Robert Jero, Mayank Bonsal, and Noel Saldana. I'm Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi.

0:31:01
Mary Childs

I'm Mary Childs. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.

0:31:12
Speaker 5

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.